Chesterton's Fence Principle

Comments discuss and explain Chesterton's Fence, the principle advising against removing or changing existing structures, rules, or traditions without first understanding their original purpose and rationale.

➡️ Stable 0.5x Other
1,001
Comments
16
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#9996
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2011
1
2012
7
2013
7
2014
3
2015
33
2016
25
2017
37
2018
36
2019
47
2020
91
2021
110
2022
189
2023
173
2024
62
2025
170
2026
12

Keywords

GP HN ycombinator.com lesswrong.com en.m slatestarcodex.com EDIT fs.blog wikipedia.org fence chesterton fence chesterton gate remove sailing exists understand rule disruption

Sample Comments

jjk166 • Jun 29, 2023 • View on HN

There is a concept known as Chesterton's Fence - that you shouldn't take down a fence someone else put up until you know why they put it up, or more generally if you don't understand why something was previously considered a good solution to a problem, then it's possible you don't understand the problem it was meant to solve.

jhncls • Feb 28, 2021 • View on HN

You seem to be hinting to Chesterton's fence [0].[0]: https://fs.blog/2020/03/chestertons-fence/

geoffeg • Jun 5, 2024 • View on HN

For those wondering, this refers to Chesterton's Fence: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G._K._Chesterton#Chesterton's_...

gumby • Feb 2, 2024 • View on HN

The difference is Chesterton's fence: when you encounter something seemingly pointless you should learn why it was there before you consider removing or changing it.

estebank • Jan 31, 2025 • View on HN

The Chesterton fence argument is that you need to understand why the fence is there. If you do understand it, and still remove it, it doesn't say that's bad.

chii • Dec 29, 2023 • View on HN

This is the chesterton's fence. Don't remove the barrier until you understood why the barrier was there first.

bombcar • Dec 11, 2025 • View on HN

It's the corollary to Chesterton's Fence - don't remove it until you know why it's there, but also investigate why it's there.

barbazoo • Aug 15, 2025 • View on HN

Chesterton’s fence isn’t “respect it forever” or “spend infinite resources”. It’s “don’t tear it down until you understand why it’s there”. The whole point is to avoid breaking something whose purpose you haven’t yet understood, because the original builders might have had a good reason that isn’t obvious to you. Once you’ve understood it, you’re free to remove it if that reason no longer applies.

pimlottc • Sep 3, 2023 • View on HN

This is more specifically known as Chesterton’s Fence:https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chesterton%27s_fence

icebraining • Sep 9, 2019 • View on HN

It's essentially the Chesterton's Fence principle.