Urban Density Preferences

Commenters debate preferences for low-density suburban or rural living with space, yards, and privacy versus high-density urban apartments, defending personal choices against pushes for more density.

📉 Falling 0.2x Politics & Society
3,172
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#9860
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
2
2009
3
2010
12
2011
11
2012
26
2013
49
2014
56
2015
86
2016
188
2017
205
2018
228
2019
229
2020
200
2021
395
2022
552
2023
445
2024
278
2025
200
2026
7

Keywords

NY US POV USA SF density dense live city high density living want live urban housing areas

Sample Comments

mrits Feb 12, 2020 View on HN

Not everyone wants to live in a dense population.

baggy_trough Aug 13, 2019 View on HN

Many, probably most, people don't want to live in density as high as that. They value greenery or simply the space to not have a neighbor breathing down their neck. What you consider preposterous is a tradeoff with other goals in mind.

rinon Mar 5, 2015 View on HN

Completely agree on your suggestions for urban areas.However, not everyone wants dense housing... Suburbs exist because people do not want to be that close to each other. Some people want to own their own yards/property/houses, have open space, and are willing to trade driving significantly more (with its associated dangers) for these features. People are going to create the kind of environment they want to live in, and we should figure out ways to make that environment better/

lotsoweiners Jul 29, 2023 View on HN

People who want to live somewhere “dense” can go live there. The dense parts of most cities don’t have mandatory single zoning or parking minimums as far as I know. I’m not going to stop you from living in or near downtown and neither is anyone else in the suburbs. You do you and let the rest of us do us.

everdrive Mar 29, 2022 View on HN

I don't think your arguments are incorrect, but I honestly couldn't imagine anything worse than needing to live in a city surrounded by people. I live in a suburb now, and it's still too dense for my tastes. I strongly believe in environmentalist issues, and I understand intellectually that we would be better off if we mostly resided in compact environments.One issue I see is that ultimately when there are enough people, choice is removed. Eventually there is only density left.

camiller Jan 26, 2012 View on HN

First, understand that I am not suggesting you or others like you are wrong, if you are happy then cool.But... I simply cannot understand the desire to live in such close proximity to large numbers of other people. Never ever again will I subject myself to high density living. I live in a suburb and simply hate having to go downtown especially when there are big events going on. The bars are crowded, eating establishments are packed, noisy has hell. Won't do it, you can't make me!I like th

electriclove Apr 18, 2023 View on HN

Thanks for providing this POV. Many of the responses here seem to think that density is a good thing. I feel the completely opposite way -> I need space. I need space away from my neighbors. I like not having other people park their cars next to my home. I like not hearing my neighbors have an argument or a party. I like not sharing the walls of my home with others. I like walking on a path by myself sometimes.There might be folks that like high density living, but please understand that t

BenFranklin100 Mar 4, 2024 View on HN

First, no one can force you or anyone else to live in a dense urban area. In fact, the denser the urban core the more less dense options right outside the city core for people such as yourself. Second, you are in the minority. Dense cities are dense for a reason: far from being anxiety-provoking, many people find urban areas very desirable place to live.

mypalmike Nov 6, 2020 View on HN

Not everyone wants "nice suburban homes" or being a landlord. Many people like city life. It's really that simple.

jimmaswell Apr 6, 2014 View on HN

A lot of people simply don't want to live in a crowded city in an apartment crowded on every side with other apartments. I'd prefer a location in a low-density suburban area (with a lot of forest around me) where I could get to the city in a few minutes.