Advice Article Critique

Commenters debate the value, originality, and practicality of advice in a specific blog article or post, praising it as insightful or dismissing it as clichéd and generic.

📉 Falling 0.4x Career & Jobs
2,970
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#9754
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
20
2008
87
2009
133
2010
179
2011
147
2012
182
2013
178
2014
110
2015
133
2016
112
2017
144
2018
176
2019
185
2020
216
2021
203
2022
228
2023
224
2024
149
2025
149
2026
15

Keywords

OP HN TBH MJ PR EXCELLENT advice good advice article giving author read apply grain salt article think basic

Sample Comments

AriaMinaei • Oct 17, 2018 • View on HN

Eloquently put! Can you recommend books/articles that'd go along with this advice?

omneity • May 5, 2025 • View on HN

Despite the tone this is excellent advice! I had similar impressions reading the article and was wondering if I missed something.

marcusgarvey • Dec 5, 2015 • View on HN

There's some good advice here beyond the clickbaity title.

jonifico • Sep 23, 2014 • View on HN

Found them a bit cliché, apart from not really giving any real advice I did't already know. Thanks for sharing, though.

plorkyeran • Nov 10, 2021 • View on HN

This seems like one of those articles which says more about the author than they intended. It's probably good advice for some people, but I can't say that I identify with it at all.

SethTro • Sep 11, 2019 • View on HN

Lots of seemingly unfiltered advice. Glad it was written up, not sure what larger lessons I should take away.

Splines • Dec 10, 2009 • View on HN

Care to elaborate? His guidance seems to be reasonable and consistent - while it should be taken with a grain of salt (some of it feels anecdotal rather than factual), I don't find it unhelpful, as you posit.

maps7 • Apr 5, 2020 • View on HN

OP, I am assuming you're the author of the article. I think it could be improved by relating it to an experience when the advice given wasn't followed. At the moment I am struggling to gain anything from it.

4monthsaway • Nov 23, 2021 • View on HN

I like this article, nice to see this type of advice without all the usual fluff

pygy_ • May 19, 2011 • View on HN

The article focuses on the motivations behind these advices and how to apply them in practice. A big part of thevalue of the article comes from this and your bullet list fails to account for that.