Racial Incarceration Disparities

The cluster centers on debates over why black Americans face disproportionately high arrest, conviction, and incarceration rates compared to whites, pitting arguments about higher black crime rates against claims of systemic racism, biased policing, and unequal enforcement.

📉 Falling 0.2x Politics & Society
3,199
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#9595
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
6
2009
4
2010
38
2011
24
2012
27
2013
154
2014
129
2015
284
2016
322
2017
208
2018
240
2019
243
2020
449
2021
408
2022
249
2023
211
2024
108
2025
82
2026
13

Keywords

US SES alternet.org nrostatic.com DotMap GIS virginia.edu amazon.com BLM hamiltonproject.org black crime black people crimes white drug incarceration blacks white people racism

Sample Comments

ddebernardy Nov 26, 2015 View on HN

Not sure why you're reading racism in that. Around a third of black men spend time behind bars in the US:http://www.alternet.org/story/154587/1_in_3_black_men_go_to_...

hwillis Jun 6, 2017 View on HN

You really can't, because black people are arrested, tried and convicted WAY disproportionately to the actual rate of crimes. eg white people smoke weed as much or more than black people, and are arrested at a far lower rate for it.

diob Sep 18, 2018 View on HN

I really encourage you to read The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness.Hand waving away racial influences is convenient to some, but definitely not to those affected by it. If you look into the statistics, you'll see that primarily minority communities were targeted by the "tough on crime" era. And these touted "tough on crime" policies only had the effect of enslaving and crippling generations of minority communities.The crime rates are

ryanmonroe Jul 8, 2016 View on HN

>The unfortunate truth is that black people are more likely to commit violent crime in the US.It doesn't make much sense to cite the proportion of black people convicted of a crime by US law enforcement as evidence refuting the claim that the US law enforcement's interaction with people changes according to their race. The proportion of black people convicted of [category] crimes could be high for many reasons, including actually higher incidence of such crimes among blacks, raci

flag_bcz_mad Jan 11, 2019 View on HN

This is like saying arresting people for being black is good because black people tend to commit crimes.

watiwaldlike2no Mar 31, 2018 View on HN

Is it fair to demand that whites and blacks be pulled over at the same rate, when whites and blacks do not commit crimes at the same rate? For example, African Americans make up 12.6% of the US population, but commit:- 52.6% of all murders [0]- 29.1% of all rapes [0]- 54.5% of all robberies [0]In fact, when it comes to almost every single violent crime category, blacks commit them at a rate that's at least twice that of whites. [0]So statistically speaking, being black is a s

onion2k Jun 11, 2020 View on HN

You would also need to control for unreported crime in non-black races. If the police ignore minor crimes by some races (eg not arresting white people found with small quantities of drugs) while they do arrest black people for the same crimes, or if the police ignore crime committed in white neighbourhoods and focus their efforts on arresting black people, then "black rates of crime are higher" is a fiction that stems from systemic police racism and isn't provably real.The prob

chneu Oct 9, 2025 View on HN

You say crime, history says racism.

hackinthebochs Nov 17, 2013 View on HN

It's been shown that while blacks have similar rates of drug use, blacks have a much higher rate of arrest, conviction, and higher sentencing. I think this is the point that was being made: the criminal justice system itself is racially biased, thus eliminating past convictions as a factor is in the spirit of eliminating racial bias.

notch656a Dec 13, 2022 View on HN

Same when comparing racial disparity in crime/prison.