AI Music Debate
The cluster centers on debates about whether AI-generated music qualifies as 'real' music, the subjectivity of musical appreciation, and defending personal enjoyment of instrumental or non-mainstream music against criticism.
Activity Over Time
Top Contributors
Keywords
Sample Comments
this is a weirdly anti art view of music as a whole, do you just not enjoy organized sound?
are you saying you appreciate music less now? or are you policing others' appreciation?
The statement might be hyperbole. But most people seem to need vocals in their music, like kind of an anchor. I mostly listen to instrumental music, and have always found it difficult to share that interest.
If music is just auditory wallpaper anyway, why distinguish?
This kind of music speaks to me in ways beyond what I feel from most "mainstream" music. Not liking it is fine, but please don't denigrate my enjoyment of it. It kills curious discussion. What is your definition of "actual music"?
Why? I'm not a music person so can't pick up on what you're signaling here
Certainly, if you don't personally enjoy it then it doesn't qualify as music.
Yes, same as people like good music :)
It's not comparable - music is art.
Nah, I just like good music. If you don't, you can't understand this.