Urban Density Debate

Comments compare population densities of US cities like San Francisco to denser international cities such as NYC, Paris, and Tokyo, debating policies restricting density, benefits for services and efficiency, and alternatives to skyscrapers.

📉 Falling 0.3x Politics & Society
4,182
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#9500
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
2
2009
16
2010
28
2011
53
2012
66
2013
111
2014
130
2015
173
2016
300
2017
258
2018
340
2019
418
2020
318
2021
444
2022
455
2023
476
2024
358
2025
227
2026
9

Keywords

US IMO WFH LED HCOL FWIW housing.html proximityone.com treehugger.com it.The density cities city dense population population density town paris downtown sprawl

Sample Comments

KptMarchewa Apr 30, 2020 View on HN

Low density compared to NYC or London or another huge city. Not a low density compared to US sprawling cities.

dajohnson89 Feb 27, 2019 View on HN

Why isn't the city allowed to be denser?

kartan Nov 24, 2018 View on HN

The solution looks good. But the remaining problem is density. The higher the density the easier is to provide services for the population. New York, Tokyo, Paris, etc, have several store tall buildings with people living in apartments. For what I see these new cities are more similar to Los Angeles or Mexico City than anything else. Single-family homes spread all over the place without access to trains or subways.I have lived all my life in apartments. So, for me, it feels normal and it is v

jbverschoor Jan 16, 2020 View on HN

What about NYC or any other densly populated area?

pcwalton Dec 17, 2019 View on HN

European cities prove that density doesn't work? What?

baby Aug 23, 2019 View on HN

Density is a bad metric because it will always be low in the US due to how cities are built.

ebikelaw Aug 15, 2018 View on HN

It is the most-dense city save for NYC, which is ten times larger. Which is my point: people think of it as dense but in reality most of it is suburban in character. There’s no need for skyscrapers to change this. A handful of 5-story buildings on major intersections would do the job.

olalonde Jan 2, 2018 View on HN

There's a simple solution... build dense cities. San Francisco feels like country side if you've lived in an actual dense city.

mixmastamyk Sep 12, 2019 View on HN

Density is preferred, ie clearing parking lots downtown, not open spaces in the country.

Depends on grandparent's definition of dense and city. You need density but you don't need tokyo, you don't need high rise and you certainly don't need lab grown meat or vertical farms.You can pack a lot of people into a 3km^2 circle at fairly moderate density when you're not wasting 500m^2 (8 parking spaces @ 40m^2 then roads, misc infrastructure and setbacks) per person forcing them to own cars.A well connected walkable rural town full of 3 story fourplexes and 2