Unrealistic Experience Requirements

The cluster focuses on job postings demanding years of experience in technologies younger than that duration or other mismatched requirements, with anecdotes like recruiters rejecting creators of the tech itself. Discussions debate if these are strict barriers, HR wish lists, or signals, and share hiring insights and application advice.

📉 Falling 0.3x Career & Jobs
3,038
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#9435
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
2
2008
13
2009
23
2010
78
2011
82
2012
139
2013
144
2014
152
2015
105
2016
220
2017
260
2018
269
2019
202
2020
215
2021
255
2022
291
2023
223
2024
217
2025
142
2026
6

Keywords

PHP DEP OpenStack ASM HR USA newsguidelines.html i.e ycombinator.com SPANNER years experience experience job hiring 10 years experience 10 years requirements number years time series job posting

Sample Comments

jarym Jul 12, 2020 View on HN

This happened to me - got a call from a recruiter who said client needed 10 years. I replied 'I was a teenager back then' to which she said 'so you don't have enough experience?'. I responded 'Well I helped create the thing, it hasn't been around 10 years'. Silence followed, I was thoroughly dis-interested after that.

exe34 Jun 16, 2024 View on HN

I'm guessing maybe it's the hiring side that wants people who already have $x number of years experience? it reminds me of the guy who wrote angular(?) and wanted to apply for a job but couldn't, because it required 8 years of experience and this was only 5 years after he wrote it.

bcbrown Jul 25, 2013 View on HN

Just because they put 3+ years experience on the job req, doesn't mean that not having 3 years experience will preclude you from consideration. Job reqs are often a wish list, and they'll hire someone who only fills some of the reqs.

millzlane Dec 20, 2023 View on HN

I recently saw a job posting that said we want someone with less than 10 years experience for a gig that seemed like 10 years of experience would be beneficial. It was a sysops gig working with ASM/DEP and workspaceONE.

mwfunk Feb 3, 2017 View on HN

In my experience, almost all of those "must have X years of experience with Y" requirements are written up by HR people who are loosely interpreting poorly understood requirements told to them by either the hiring manager, or other HR people. In many or most cases, the people writing up those job postings are not the same people who would be interviewing or hiring you, and they're more aspirational requirements than anything else. They hope that someone with X years of experience

kardos Mar 29, 2018 View on HN

Don't forget that people with 3+ years experience probably aren't applying for entry level jobs

adamnemecek Sep 25, 2013 View on HN

It's missing the obligatory "We are looking for someone with n years of experience." where n > age of the project.

qq66 Nov 25, 2012 View on HN

I've seen several job ads requiring "5+ years experience with Technology X" where Technology X is not yet 5 years old.

stefanmichael Oct 4, 2023 View on HN

feel free to have them reach out for feedback about why we passed on them, I offer that to anyone who asks. we have taken screens with new grads and folks with less than 2 years of professional experience from this job posting already so I assure you that line is accurate.

thisisit Sep 5, 2017 View on HN

Good advice but as many are pointing out, many a times the job description will have some kid of "number of years experience" requirement. Even if it means asking for X number of years when the technology has existed for X-N years.