Manga vs Western Comics

Cluster focuses on comparisons between manga and Western comics/graphic novels, emphasizing manga's cultural depth, accessibility, market success in Asia, and potential with AI generation.

📉 Falling 0.2x Other
1,414
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#9380
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
1
2008
1
2009
10
2010
24
2011
21
2012
28
2013
23
2014
35
2015
99
2016
33
2017
34
2018
40
2019
146
2020
78
2021
126
2022
251
2023
172
2024
191
2025
96
2026
5

Keywords

CS NY US MANGA WEBTOON HN NA webnovel.com BS DC manga comics japanese anime comic novels graphic novel books japan

Sample Comments

visarga Oct 18, 2019 View on HN

Manga and anime - get some exposure.

rtaycher Mar 4, 2011 View on HN

Expected this to be about Japanese comics.

chainwax Jan 21, 2022 View on HN

Oh cmon, MANGA is so much better

liqilin1567 Oct 23, 2025 View on HN

Manga may come to life with this :D

neonbones Aug 25, 2021 View on HN

When I was at school, I watch hundreds of titles every year, but after some time, when my taste became more mature, I've started to be much pickier about anime and usually just read manga. Even with my primary career as a software engineer (and product manager for now), I love to draw, and it's always fun to see some extremely detailed manga art. It inspires me to draw something too, but I know that manga authors' work conditions are worse than in the shittiest startup you can im

bowsamic Dec 12, 2022 View on HN

Manga is more culturally developed, but it's just that it makes less money

watwut Jun 6, 2017 View on HN

The word comic comes with expectations about graphics style and content, same as manga has some expectations (through that has more variety of stuff). That is quite practical for people like me who don't like the comic style, but do enjoy differently painted pictures with bubbles.Does not mean it must somehow inherently superior, it is more of attempt to sell to people who are aware of how it looks like usually and that they usually dont like it.

cinquemb Mar 14, 2012 View on HN

This was a interesting read! Thanks for sharing! I wonder if there is something like this that speaks to manga.

wwwtyro Oct 30, 2024 View on HN

With consistent representation of characters, are we now on the precipice of a Cambrian explosion of manga/graphic novels/comics?

deafpolygon Dec 12, 2022 View on HN

Korean entertainment industry does well at exploiting what works. Korean webtoons are short, quick, updated frequently, accessible, easy to read on the phone, everyone has a mobile, and that is what is done. Not to mention that there is a culture of translating everything into English as quickly as possible in Korea.In contrast, mangas are often bought in book form (which are less and less attractive as time goes on), cost more, less accessible, and have a lower update frequency. Japanese e