SF Housing Crisis

The cluster discusses skyrocketing housing prices in San Francisco and the Bay Area, attributing the crisis primarily to insufficient housing supply caused by NIMBYism and regulatory barriers rather than the tech industry's influx of high-paid workers, with calls to build more housing.

📉 Falling 0.1x Politics & Society
4,079
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#9272
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
2
2008
1
2009
4
2010
9
2011
19
2012
63
2013
315
2014
342
2015
265
2016
508
2017
324
2018
388
2019
445
2020
373
2021
287
2022
218
2023
331
2024
106
2025
75
2026
4

Keywords

e.g US SF DOLLARS IMO qz.com theatlantic.com www.vox NYC strongtowns.org housing sf san francisco francisco san tech city bay area bay housing prices

Sample Comments

quanticle Jan 3, 2014 View on HN

Everything in this article comes back to housing. That's not the tech. industry's fault. The tech. industry would love to have more housing in San Francisco and the rest of the Bay Area. Housing prices have increased so quickly, and are currently at such a high level that even highly paid tech. workers are thinking twice about moving to SF. We see it often enough in the comment threads right here.The problem is that the existing residents of San Francisco would like to preser

triceratops Apr 5, 2023 View on HN

Maybe SF should've tried approving more housing so rich techies didn't drive up rents and displace existing communities.

twblalock May 26, 2019 View on HN

People are moving to San Francisco to take high-paying jobs and there is not enough luxury housing to accommodate them, so they are out-competing poorer people for whatever housing they can get. If more luxury housing was built, those people would take it and leave the rest of the housing for other people.

lettergram Jan 26, 2014 View on HN

Seems kind of silly to me, yes this means that many people have to leave the city, but there really is not much that they can do about it. San Francisco's city government is not going to be able to either (a) kick out the tech people nor (b) figure out a way to lower rent (and in turn tax revenue). It's in the cities interest to keep the rent/cost per home as high as possible and in turn keep the tech people around.I really don't understand why this bothers the others in t

rayiner Sep 28, 2012 View on HN

It is a matter of supply and demand, and while demand in SF is high, it's nothing like say NYC or LA where there are millions of people looking for housing. SF is a medium-sized city as far as cities go. It's a growing city, unlike many, but in the last ten years it grew slower than Boston, DC, Portland, Seattle, San Diego, and Miami. It's not like developers can't build housing quickly enough to keep up with all the demand. It's that the city won't let them.

manfredo Oct 26, 2018 View on HN

The situation in San Francisco is mostly due to NIMBYism and a refusal to build housing. Tech jobs don't magically make housing prices rise - shortages of housing make housing prices rise. Seattle is handling this better than SF, in large part because SF had messed with the natural interaction of supply and demand. Given what the above commenter wrote, Berlin looks like it is in the same situation as SF: trying to solve a housing shortage by discouraging demand rather than increasing supply

m0llusk Jun 25, 2014 View on HN

This is happening because a huge imbalance between supply and demand for housing was created by activist locals just like this. Anyone who seriously wants to address this will have to back off of the opposition and naysaying to development and get on with building more units for the many people who are moving to San Francisco.People in tech being successful and buying property is not the problem. The problem is a lack of available property to by caused by unreasonably restrictive policies t

TulliusCicero May 18, 2016 View on HN

San Francisco is more in its people than its buildings. By constricting the supply of housing, they've inadvertently pushed out the very 'weirdos' they were trying to keep; it's pretty easy for the rich to outbid the poor.

boomshucka Jul 8, 2015 View on HN

That's not even close to what it's saying. It's saying people in places like SF don't want others coming in/and or want to maximize their home value, so they stop new housing being built, which keeps supply of housing down and thus less people can live in areas where there are lots of work opportunities.

justinzollars Jun 15, 2018 View on HN

After living here since 2009 I think I've figured out the Bay Area and San Francisco. SF is a city that doesn't want to be a city. It just doesn't want to grow up. Silicon Valley has since spilled over into San Francisco and we have a combination of massive job growth, prosperity and extremely limited new construction. Every year more people arrive than we construct housing for.Compounding the problem are many local politicians. Serious local political players are divorced from