Internet Balkanization

The cluster discusses governments worldwide imposing controls, firewalls, and restrictions that fragment the global internet into national silos, challenging the ideal of a universal open network.

➡️ Stable 0.6x Politics & Society
2,889
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#9038
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
1
2008
4
2009
20
2010
69
2011
130
2012
185
2013
151
2014
89
2015
93
2016
132
2017
162
2018
180
2019
212
2020
231
2021
247
2022
301
2023
217
2024
172
2025
257
2026
36

Keywords

NY e.g US AMD DNS HN SHOULD ARE UN IP internet countries china governments access internet access russia foreign firewalls nationality

Sample Comments

efdee Oct 17, 2013 View on HN

I assume the point is that countries don't want to break with "The Internet", just "The American Internet".

jrockway Mar 24, 2010 View on HN

Are these countries trying to kill the Internet?

exit May 6, 2011 View on HN

i'd like to see a movement which clearly places the internet above the sovereignty of any nation

sreevisakh Aug 27, 2020 View on HN

You shouldn't judge other countries by western standards. There are a lot of places with poor or non-existent internet. But I fear that the reason other countries will do the same is because of their current infrastructure. Capable countries would be weary of ceding the control of their internet to American companies. We already have a splintered internet with countries and companies addicted to monitoring and controlling information (which would have been impossible in the first place if i

srcmap Dec 25, 2019 View on HN

Welcome to Balkanization of internet.As much as internet Jedi like a free/secure internet, the force of Empires (governments of ru, UAE, cn, US, UK, EU, etc) are striking back.It is not "some" countries. It is "all" countries - they all feel the power/needs to monitor, control the internet.

herbst Apr 13, 2023 View on HN

Why would any one country be able to decide which other countries have access to the internet? Where is freedom if this is where are are at?

supertrope Jun 30, 2025 View on HN

The Internet is by definition universal. Autonomous Systems make their own routing decisions. We cannot cut them off the Internet any more than we can cut off their sea access. If we were to do so (analogous to a naval blockade) you'd have succeeded in only cutting off civilians. Government sponsored or tolerated criminals would still ply their trade like in N Korea.

CodeArtisan Dec 13, 2022 View on HN

Internet is already partitioned, especially when it come to China (Great firewall). You say to do like EU but it made things worse; For example, this is what i get when i try to browse yahoo.co.jp:https://abload.de/img/screenshot2022-12-13aa4exy.pngNY Daily news:https:&#

DominikR Mar 21, 2016 View on HN

I believe that this kind of behaviour will be the reason why the Internet as we know it and are used to it will end some day.We will have many island solutions with firewalls around them just to prevent foreign powers from interfering in internal political processes.For example I certainly do not like what Erdogan is doing in Turkey (cutting off Facebook and Twitter), but is he wrong when he is accusing foreign powers from trying to incite demonstrations or manipulate public opinion? I

bdunbar May 6, 2011 View on HN

places the internet above the sovereignty of any nationHow would that work?