Birthplace and Nationality Debates
The cluster centers on arguments about whether public figures like Elon Musk are 'American' based on birthplace, citizenship, naturalization, or residency, often challenging assumptions of native-born status.
📉 Falling 0.5x Politics & Society
2,225
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#894
Topic ID
Activity Over Time
2007 7
2008 14
2009 31
2010 45
2011 78
2012 96
2013 112
2014 93
2015 85
2016 132
2017 124
2018 121
2019 158
2020 154
2021 162
2022 230
2023 224
2024 149
2025 195
2026 17
Top Contributors
Keywords
QED US i.e U.S wikipedia.org born american nationality south africa africa hungarian apartheid canada south immigrant
Sample Comments
He or she is probably not North American.
How do they know he is from the US?
I think nobody doubts that he is a US American. He was just born in South Africa.
He wasn’t born in the US, can’t.
I assume that he is not American from the "small country" bit.
Because he was not born in neither Serbia or the US.
Technically wasn't his father born in the US?
Looks like he is from Switzerland. Must be different there.
Lol. Not even. What about Musk. He is not born in US
I'm Polish born but raised in Canada. Does that count?