LED vs Incandescent Bulbs

The cluster focuses on debates comparing LED and incandescent light bulbs, discussing their lifespan, efficiency, reliability, heat management, power supply issues, color rendering, and personal experiences with failures or successes.

📉 Falling 0.3x Hardware
4,624
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#8929
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
6
2008
19
2009
54
2010
18
2011
150
2012
73
2013
263
2014
186
2015
137
2016
243
2017
190
2018
246
2019
446
2020
316
2021
350
2022
352
2023
876
2024
349
2025
335
2026
15

Keywords

e.g CRI LED AC LCD A19 CFL MR16 slate.com budgetlightforum.com bulbs leds led bulb lights watt lighting light power supply heat

Sample Comments

ashkankiani Feb 15, 2021 View on HN

Stockpiling incadescent bulbs instead of spending time doing research to find LED bulbs with a better light spectrum?

dreamcompiler May 7, 2019 View on HN

The dirty secret of LED lighting is that while LEDs themselves last a long time, they only do so in the presence of good power supply design and good thermal design. If you cut corners on the power supply or thermal management, LEDs will burn out much quicker than older lighting technologies. The majority of consumer-grade LED "bulbs" available today are shitty on both counts, AFAICT.

oblio Dec 22, 2022 View on HN

Your anecdata is bad. Even after the conspiracy was discovered, incandescent bulbs still had a much lower life expectancy than LED lights.It's simple physics :-)

rozab Apr 12, 2021 View on HN

Why are incandescent light bulbs inferior, exactly?

frosted-flakes Jun 18, 2025 View on HN

Incandescent lights are still widely available if you still want them. Nonetheless, modern high quality LED lights can actually exceed the colour rendering index of incandescent lights, though they tend to be a little more expensive. I don't think it's a big deal to pay $15 for a bulb that will still be there in 15 years.

jdietrich Apr 7, 2019 View on HN

The efficiency of an incandescent lightbulb is directly proportional to its lifespan. Long-life incandescent bulbs are a false economy.The problem with LEDs is simply that people buy based solely on price. A Yuji high-CRI LED lamp is genuinely indistinguishable from an incandescent lamp, but you'll never see one in a hardware store because they're slightly more expensive.https:

Yardlink Jul 15, 2014 View on HN

I'm surprised they still use glass incandescent bulbs instead of LEDs. Perhaps it's cheaper?

HeyLaughingBoy Dec 29, 2010 View on HN

This is a problem with LED lights, but it's not a problem with the technology.LED are expensive now, but the price/performance ratio and efficiency are improving rapidly. And as the other poster said, when designed in properly into new installations they can have excellent performance. But their lighting and heat dissipation characteristics are so different that they really don't do well when retrofitted into fixtures that were designed for incandescents or fluorescents.The problem is that

iamerroragent Apr 13, 2023 View on HN

"Only the LEDs I have in table lamps have survived more than five years. All enclosed bulbs die from cheap components and heat damage. "Part of the problem is trying to make LEDs work in our preexisting lighting systems which requires components to make a low voltage DC light work with our existing AC wiring.https://hackaday.com/20

throwaway290 Jan 16, 2025 View on HN

Three led lights in my flat went within 3 months after I moved in. But some time ago I had an incandescent bulb that lived for years.With bulb it depends on how/how often you power cycle. A good way to extend its life is to not power cycle it and to underpower it. Dimming a bulb also saves electricity and easier on the eyes.With LED it is up to manufacturer. People say LEDs are cheaper but those leds are exactly the ones you have to keep buying. And good LED prices can go pretty high