Open Source License Lawsuits

Comments discuss legal risks, lawsuits, and enforcement of open source licenses like GPL, including violations by closing source code, cease and desist letters, and contacting organizations like EFF for defense.

📉 Falling 0.4x Open Source
4,046
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#8899
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
7
2008
27
2009
71
2010
94
2011
131
2012
126
2013
151
2014
155
2015
186
2016
194
2017
184
2018
179
2019
193
2020
256
2021
467
2022
421
2023
511
2024
351
2025
320
2026
24

Keywords

RC EFF GH AI HN YC IMHO OSS FSF GPL sue legal open source software license source sued open company court

Sample Comments

tommi Apr 5, 2012 View on HN

Does it make you more vulnerable to law suits if the author says no and you decide to code/acquire something similar?

enz Apr 21, 2021 View on HN

I wonder if they can be sued (by the Linux Foundation, maybe) for that...

You can sue them for using your code if they break the licensing agreement. Contact EFF and they'll set you up with a lawyer.

spywaregorilla May 19, 2024 View on HN

Do you want a world where google can sue your open source project because it utilizes it's style of coding?

Aeolun Sep 27, 2021 View on HN

Who’s going to sue someone taking it closed source?

squarefoot Sep 24, 2024 View on HN

Interesting to see how would this play out in case of a lawsuit against an user who doesn't honor their license because it clashes with GH one. Anyway, that code has already been swallowed by some AI that will reorganize it, split in functional blocks and regurgitate it elsewhere someday, so too late for them to complain.

drclegg Jun 6, 2023 View on HN

Not a lawyer, but it's probably a bad idea to open-source something _after_ getting a C&D for it

rcxdude Oct 21, 2020 View on HN

Probably not. The consequence of violating the (A)GPL is you lose the right to use, distribute, and modify the software. They could in principle be sued because they were violating the license while the website is up but you'd need to demonstrate losses and you couldn't force the release, only get some compensation (though you could try to use that as leverage to settle for the release of the code). (IANAL, etc)

bastawhiz Sep 16, 2023 View on HN

You know, you're totally correct that they're well within their right to do... something. But why? What damages could they collect? It would take far less cash to rewrite the library I made from scratch than it would to pay lawyers to write some scary letters. There's no trade secrets. It's not even a novel idea. It would be terribly expensive and embarrassing for either Box or Uber to try to juice this even if they were motivated to. Hell, I'm technically still an activ

leephillips Dec 25, 2021 View on HN

It depends on how that code is licensed. Possibly the random person gets served with a summons. Possibly nothing.