Iran Nuclear Program Debate

Comments debate Iran's pursuit of nuclear weapons, Israel's and US opposition including strikes and sabotage, hypocrisy claims regarding Israel's nukes, and arguments for Iran needing nukes for deterrence against aggression.

🚀 Rising 3.8x Politics & Society
3,138
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#8891
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
4
2008
5
2009
15
2010
42
2011
91
2012
150
2013
67
2014
37
2015
113
2016
58
2017
50
2018
94
2019
215
2020
250
2021
376
2022
128
2023
141
2024
271
2025
964
2026
69

Keywords

US IMHO JCS THE thehill.com IAEA NSA U.S ONLY B2 iran israel nuclear nukes iranian weapons nuclear weapons bomb facilities israeli

Sample Comments

monkaiju Jun 22, 2025 View on HN

Iran doesnt have and hasnt pursued a nuclear weapons program: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/jun/17/trump-iran-i...

samrus Jun 22, 2025 View on HN

if israel and america actually believed iran was as close to nukes as bibi said it was, then the variance on the prediction, and the chance of iran already having nukes and already being able to deliver them via ballistic/hamas means would be too large to risk something like thisnorth korea and pakistan actually have nukes. we can be sure of that because of the bullshit they get up to with full impunity from the US. iran doesnt have shit (and it might even have been working in good faith

popileviz Sep 18, 2021 View on HN

Iran should have nuclear weapons if their citizens can be assassinated by foreign powers that proceed to brag about it openly. Imagine if the reverse happened - an Israeli scientist killed by Iranian special forces. The United States would be revving up for Iraq 2.0 in a matter of hours.

tharmas Jun 22, 2025 View on HN

Israel has nukes, so why would they be afraid of Iran?

DiogenesKynikos Jun 23, 2025 View on HN

Nuclear weapons are already in the hands of crazy Jewish ethnonationalists and religious nuts. Those guys have been going completely crazy for the last two years, carrying out a genocide in Gaza, invading Lebanon and Syria, and attacking Iran.By comparison, the Iranian goverment looks calm and rational. Israel has attacked Iran three separate times in just the last two years. The first two times, Iran tried to prevent escalation by calibrating its response and informing Israel beforehand.I

markyc Aug 29, 2017 View on HN

Iran has officially stated they want Israel obliterated, and then they started building up nukes, so not sure how sane or defensive they are

placebo May 18, 2018 View on HN

source/citation (not so much for the nukes, but for wanting to wipe out Iran)?

samrus Jun 22, 2025 View on HN

if iran had nukes, israel and america wouldnt have dared bomb it. iran wasnt even close, and they must be kicking themselves for that now

Because it could ONLY be Iran which doesn't want USA to have nuclear weapons...Historically speaking, USA is more likely to drop an atomic bomb than Iran (or any other country for that matter)

nitrogen Apr 13, 2012 View on HN

Many in the US have said the same thing about Iran. When all it takes is one nuke, why should Iran wait to find out? See the hypocrisy? Existential threats work both ways. Are those US talking heads and politicians "brainwashed religious fanatics?" A more important question is why Iran('s government) wants (or claims to want) to eliminate Israel, and how to change their mind (or their government) peacefully.