Ex-Convict Employment Barriers

Commenters debate how prison records hinder ex-convicts from finding jobs, leading to higher recidivism rates, and advocate for rehabilitation, second chances, and societal reintegration to break the cycle of reoffending.

📉 Falling 0.3x Politics & Society
3,145
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#8807
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
15
2009
17
2010
29
2011
23
2012
45
2013
167
2014
99
2015
224
2016
160
2017
252
2018
302
2019
311
2020
225
2021
290
2022
316
2023
291
2024
202
2025
170
2026
7

Keywords

e.g US IMHO GTA ML UBI prison crime crimes commit crimes society jail commit ex life criminals

Sample Comments

mytherin Aug 2, 2017 View on HN

Do you really think preventing people from getting jobs makes them less likely to commit crimes in the future? To me it seems the opposite is much more likely. If people are unable to make an honest living they will be forced to commit crimes to make ends meet.The prison sentence is the punishment for the crime. After people are let out of prison they should be reintegrated into society.

spywaregorilla Mar 14, 2022 View on HN

Seems to me he's in the same spot he is now, except materially less employable due to a prison sentence. Do you think your idea here really seems probable to work?

dx034 Apr 13, 2018 View on HN

Even if that was his crime it shouldn't prevent him from getting a job. Forcing people to drop out of the labour market massively increases the chance of them committing another crime. Rehabilitation works best if you give people a second chance.

Let's break this down. Someone commits murder, and gets sent to prison for 13 years. They are out now. How do we deal with them?1. If everyone says that they will no longer want to work with such a person, especially rich people, who can enforce that want, that person will end up working with poor people. The rich people are making a classist argument.2. Worse, if that person, cannot even get bad jobs, they will be forced to commit more crimes in order to live. Now, the first crime mi

dj_mc_merlin Oct 2, 2020 View on HN

What will satisfy you then? Should people who come out from prison for stealing sit around jobless since nobody trusts them? That's bound to get them back into prison.

sershe Oct 28, 2022 View on HN

I thought we were all about making it easier for felons to reintegrate into society? ;)

Cyberdog Mar 9, 2018 View on HN

No ex-convict wants to return to prison. However, they've just been put in a position where all of their peers are also criminals, and getting a well-compensated job after release is incredibly difficult, especially if they do not already have specialized skills and education. So it's very easy to fall back into bad habits, especially if that's how they were paying the bills.Destigmatizing a criminal record when it comes to hiring (or anything else for that matter) would help a

misterhtmlcss Jun 16, 2018 View on HN

We don't want them to re-offend, but we won't give them meaningful work either. Terrible cycle

jacquesm Nov 1, 2016 View on HN

None of the things you mention would stop someone from re-entering society, in quite a few countries there are rehabilitation programmes in the jails with gradual re-introduction to 'normal' life after longer jail sentences.Yes, this costs money but it helps to reduce recidivism and in general is a good thing to do.

apsec112 Jul 5, 2020 View on HN

This culture of "never forget, no excuses, no forgiveness" is part of why the US has so many people in prison. Suppose someone commits an armed robbery. They should be arrested, certainly, for many reasons. But after they have been tried, punished, and served their sentence, should they be permanently exiled from society? Should they never be able to find employment for the rest of their life? No, because that doesn't help anyone and just creates more crime. This person is probabl