Desalination Brine Disposal

The cluster discusses the environmental challenges and disposal methods for the concentrated salty brine produced by seawater desalination plants, including risks of local salinity increases, harm to marine life, and potential uses or dilutions.

📉 Falling 0.2x Science
2,956
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#8478
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
2
2008
1
2009
12
2010
15
2011
36
2012
26
2013
46
2014
59
2015
118
2016
99
2017
139
2018
141
2019
370
2020
159
2021
370
2022
337
2023
585
2024
276
2025
156
2026
9

Keywords

GP scientificamerican.com menk.com firefighterinsider.com I.e wired.com www.nps basin.htm wikipedia.org salt water ocean sea salty dumped minerals dump plant waste

Sample Comments

lucb1e Jul 30, 2016 View on HN

I assume it's about the salt that is dumped back into the ocean after removing the water from it.

spockz Jul 2, 2021 View on HN

Yes. So it is not an issue for the device. However, the salt does end up back in the ocean where at scale the salt levels will be higher leading to the (edit: local) environmental issues mentioned by the GP.

anon1253 Oct 14, 2019 View on HN

Straight up dumping it in the ocean is generally considered bad. The standard trick is to wash/mix the brine with fresh ocean water to reduce the concentration of salt before dumping it back. Another interesting byproduct that is often overlooked are the metals and minerals. Things like lithium (and even gold) are relatively abundant in sea water and could be recovered from the brine (at the cost of complexity of course).

everdrive Oct 18, 2019 View on HN

Where does the salt go when you desalinate? At a large enough scale, would we risk salting some area (or body of water) to death?

ceejayoz Mar 13, 2015 View on HN

It probably wouldn't. Desalinization leaves a lot of salty brine to be disposed of.

mschuster91 May 4, 2021 View on HN

With anything involving seawater, you'll run into the same issues as any desalination plant - where to put the enormous amounts of brine? Potable water is bad enough to electrolyze as there are lots of minerals in it, but salt water is a whole lot worse - and there are massive concerns about the toxicity of brine.

nuc1e0n Dec 14, 2022 View on HN

My thinking is that if you dump brine into the sea you're a putting in a liquid that marine life can swim though and be harmed by. Another problem is just how to get the byproducts of desalination away from the plant.If the salt were made into a boat, it could be sailed away (moved more easily than on land) and could mix with seawater over a much wider area. Even if it sinks after a short period, it would still be in a rock-like form that would mix with seawater over a longer time perio

derekp7 Apr 12, 2015 View on HN

Dump it on the roads in the North during the winter.Or, more seriously, if it is salt that was extracted from the sea, there shouldn't be much harm in putting it back. The fresh water that was extracted will end up back in the sea also, so overall there should be no increase in salinity (except locally where the salt is dumped).

mirekrusin May 12, 2016 View on HN

Isn't it going to create local ultra salty water?

cpncrunch Mar 21, 2015 View on HN

The salt was in the water to begin with. If you read that reference that you posted, you'll see that the problem is the waste chemicals (not salt), and the increase in temperature of the water. It's plausible that they could filter out the waste chemicals, but I'm not sure about the heat.