Parler Deplatforming Debate

The cluster discusses Parler's shutdown by Apple, Amazon, Google, and others for failing to moderate calls for violence and hate speech, often comparing it to similar content on Twitter, Facebook, and Reddit. Debates focus on free speech, censorship hypocrisy, and platform responsibilities.

📉 Falling 0.1x Politics & Society
2,567
Comments
8
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#8448
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2018
1
2020
138
2021
2,276
2022
107
2023
25
2024
11
2025
8
2026
1

Keywords

AFAIK FB US YC TechDirt twitter.com DC AWS ISIS techdirt.com parler twitter facebook facebook twitter speech violence moderate content moderation free speech

Sample Comments

rat87 Feb 1, 2021 View on HN

Are you referring to the way that Parler censors views it doesn't agree with?

nekochanwork Jan 11, 2021 View on HN

Twitter, Reddit, and Facebook ban people all the time for calls to violence. Reddit made the national news last year because moderators of r/The_Donald failed to police the numerous posts of users who plotted to murder the governor of Michigan.Parler, by contrast, did not moderate calls to violence. It quickly became a safe space for neo-fascists to plan, coordinate, and execute plots against the US government.Parler was playing a completely different game to Twitter, Reddit, and FB.

kerng Jan 11, 2021 View on HN

Why is Parler shut down and Facebook not?

boublepop Jan 12, 2021 View on HN

There isn’t really anything related to free speech here. No one censored parler, let alone the government. Amazon and Apple didn’t even censor them, just refused to support their product because they failed to live up to the terms of service.The only element of free speech ironically was that Parler was found to censor left-leaning and moderate messages in its forum.

mensetmanusman Jan 10, 2021 View on HN

Parler failed to moderate to the standards of Facebook, Amazon, and Twitter, oh my

olliej Jan 14, 2021 View on HN

Twitter very aggressively filters, suspends, and bans people for posting violence, promotion of violence, attacks on groups based on religion, race, etcParler actively avoided moderating even explicitly called out posts by their own service provider.In fact the only thing parler apparently moderated was insufficiently right wing accounts, as accounts apparently started off shadow banned until their account was found to be sufficiently right wing.

andyxor Sep 6, 2021 View on HN

create a better alternative to Parler, more robust against de-platforming by Bigtech, half the country will thank you

spankalee Jan 11, 2021 View on HN

What "single" post are you talking about?Parler had thousands of offending posts and users and refused to moderate at all after being told to to be in compliance with various ToS.It's no surprise that Amazon, Apple, Google, Twilio, etc., do not want to be associated with or support violent seditionists.

m3kw9 Jan 14, 2021 View on HN

Parler got destroyed and fb gets what? A slap on the wrist

surge Jan 17, 2021 View on HN

Your*Most of the people who are saying this never actually looked at the site, the reality is the majority of the content seen was no worse than that of Twitter, in some ways better and more politer (that's what you get with an echo chamber), but every argument leveraged against Parler could be leveraged 10x over against Twitter. So no matter what intentions are, the effect is the same. You can't in good faith argue Parler deserves to be taken down anymore than Twitter and many oth