Cancel Culture Self-Censorship

Comments focus on the fear of expressing unpopular opinions publicly due to risks like job loss, cancellation, or social backlash, resulting in self-censorship and stifled discourse.

📉 Falling 0.4x Politics & Society
3,697
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#8316
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
1
2008
2
2009
29
2010
32
2011
42
2012
69
2013
138
2014
111
2015
150
2016
183
2017
329
2018
206
2019
322
2020
479
2021
501
2022
394
2023
271
2024
173
2025
248
2026
17

Keywords

say.html QED US HN wikipedia.org PG paulgraham.com youtube.com TV MLK opinions expressing social unpopular views fear opinion cancelled risk speaking

Sample Comments

voakbasda Mar 8, 2022 View on HN

That’s not possible. People take offense at everything. Or they will tomorrow.That’s the real problem: the standards of “good” and “decent” shift from time to time. What is fine today may get you canceled tomorrow.Thus, it is not safe to put your opinions out there in any form that could come back to bite you. If you want to take that risk, fine. But do not pretend that it is safe.

bitcurious Jun 23, 2020 View on HN

People are getting fired and publicly shamed for statements and actions made one, two decades ago. It’s entirely reasonable to be afraid of speaking something acceptable but unpopular today out of fear that it will be unacceptable tomorrow.

cpursley Sep 1, 2022 View on HN

When your livelihood is as stake for expressing the wrong views (and I mean outside of the workplace), of course people are going to stop being public about them. And this is really dangerous because going underground is where the really nasty stuff festers.Can't we all just be nice and not personally go after people and instead debate their views in the open?

eanzenberg Dec 14, 2017 View on HN

Those people probably have more to lose now if they spoke freely of ideas that were antithetical to their surroundings.

tgdfhgfh Apr 4, 2014 View on HN

Don't you see? If anyone decides to say an unpopular opinion that offends the left, their lives and careers would probably be ruined. Doesn't that stifle conversation? How is that a good thing?

aganders3 Apr 4, 2014 View on HN

No, there are no thought police. There are, however, consequences among your social peers and professional colleagues for public statements. There is no reasonable free speech protection you can put in place to change this.Throughout history, groups have always sought to stifle alternative thought. The moral difference is in the tactics they use, which have ranged from censorship to violence and bribery to peaceful protest and civil disobedience. I, for one, prefer and even encourage <

RestlessMind Nov 28, 2020 View on HN

> But insofar as this conversation, I don’t see anyone being cancelled or shut down for an opinionBecause this conversation allows me to be anonymous. I simply don't dare expressing my thoughts with my real identity attached. Who knows whether I will get cancelled or fired.The people working on suppression of certain viewpoints have hurt themselves in the long run. Now I am seeing candid discussions happening only in small trusted circles or on anonymous forums. That can be another

DougN7 Aug 15, 2014 View on HN

This is sad but true. One option is to remove anonimity, but with the online vigilantism(?) we see towards unpopular opinions, I personally would choose to be quiet than take the risk of voicing an unpopular opinion. And squelching debate isn't a good option either.

gms Dec 29, 2013 View on HN

It's very unfortunate. I am too scared to voice opinions on these subjects on public forums due to the potential outrage people would react with, which may effect my career.I really think that people secretly enjoy being outraged.

wolco2 Oct 19, 2020 View on HN

I think he was lamenting the loss of priority of privacy within the general hn makeup.If everyone took your advice no one would protest, write a political comment against anyone in power, take any position that isn't accepted by all and be ready to drop that opinion when society shifts.You live in a free society. Use your freedom or risk losing it.