Species Concept Debate

The cluster focuses on the challenges and ambiguities in defining biological species, frequently referencing ring species, the species problem, interbreeding criteria, and the arbitrary nature of species boundaries.

πŸ“‰ Falling 0.5x Science
2,403
Comments
18
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#8314
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2009
16
2010
40
2011
39
2012
33
2013
62
2014
76
2015
139
2016
207
2017
144
2018
133
2019
168
2020
191
2021
277
2022
181
2023
251
2024
242
2025
196
2026
8

Keywords

CS A1 BBC A2 royalsocietypublishing.org stanford.edu en.m wikipedia.org DNA species breed offspring organisms mammals biology island concept bacteria evolutionary

Sample Comments

adrianN β€’ Nov 25, 2017 β€’ View on HN

Yes. See for example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_species

keiferski β€’ Oct 17, 2024 β€’ View on HN

You will probably find this article about the species concept interesting:https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/species/

irrational β€’ Jul 23, 2022 β€’ View on HN

Isn’t the human species a ring species?

Amezarak β€’ Nov 14, 2014 β€’ View on HN

I think of it like this: there's not really any such thing as a "species" in nature. It's an abstraction we developed to make sense of the world. In reality, organisms exist on a huge continuum composed of individuals which are more or less genetically similar/related. Often there are huge "chunks" missing where lines died out or went their separate ways. We arbitrarily declare that such-and-such collection of organisms between this point and that point on the

ummonk β€’ May 9, 2023 β€’ View on HN

Consider: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_species

skybrian β€’ Oct 2, 2016 β€’ View on HN

Here's one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_species

baddox β€’ Aug 29, 2013 β€’ View on HN

Yes. Basically, the http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Species_problem.

Turing_Machine β€’ Oct 16, 2015 β€’ View on HN

It's not that simple. Suppose you have a group of animals spread across a large continent.The ones on the eastern side can breed successfully with the ones in the center.The ones on the western side can also breed successfully with the ones in the center.The ones on the eastern side are different enough from the ones on the west that they can't breed successfully.How many species are there? :-)It's a continuum, not a binary relation.It's very similar

zests β€’ Feb 12, 2021 β€’ View on HN

It's not easy to define "species".https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Species_concept

Amezarak β€’ Dec 13, 2016 β€’ View on HN

There is no bright line between species, ergo there is no point we can stop and say "there! it's speciated!"'Species' just an arbitrary dividing line humans invented. The reality is much, much messier. We might call something a different species, but it might still be able to breed with some other species. It might not ever do so because of proximity. It might not ever do so due to some minor characteristic throwing off mate signalling. Maybe it does, but the offsprin