Cast Iron Cookware Debate

Cluster centers on debates about cast iron, carbon steel, and stainless steel pans versus non-stick Teflon, emphasizing seasoning for non-stick performance, durability, and cooking techniques like eggs.

📉 Falling 0.1x Other
3,352
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#8294
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
2
2008
3
2009
3
2010
8
2011
11
2012
12
2013
55
2014
106
2015
101
2016
59
2017
118
2018
131
2019
154
2020
118
2021
569
2022
866
2023
546
2024
407
2025
79
2026
4

Keywords

e.g MAYBE seriouseats.com IMO HN OK IKEA bluskilletironware.com CIC www.oxo pan iron cast stainless steel pans stick cooking eggs carbon

Sample Comments

daveyjonezz • Aug 12, 2022 • View on HN

Cast iron pans are cheap, will outlive you, and work nearly as well with enough seasoning / butter :)

neolog • Jul 29, 2021 • View on HN

Why not just use a stainless steel pan?

jdkee • Jan 23, 2020 • View on HN

Not with properly seasoned cast-iron cookware, it won't.

moi2388 • Sep 15, 2025 • View on HN

I only cook on cast iron or stainless steel. I have no problems with the consistency of cooking. No clue what they’re on about

thezilch • Aug 12, 2015 • View on HN

I've never understood the gravity of Teflon pans. I can never seem to keep them non-stick, whether it be because of using too high of heat or somehow scratch the damn thing.So, I got cast irons. It's trivial to keep them seasoned and thus non-stick, and they can take the beating of very high heat -- searing meats -- and any metal utensils or rough substances.

nommm-nommm • Dec 19, 2016 • View on HN

You don't even need cast iron, I use stainless steel just fine.

pdq • Nov 5, 2023 • View on HN

Get a Carbon Steel pan instead.These are similar metal composition to cast iron, where you can season them with oils, but are forged (ie pressed) into shape, rather than cast. So you get a smooth surface, which is easier for non-stick use and lighter weight.Carbon steel are better for eggs, omelettes, etc, but cast iron are often better for steaks/meats, because they retain heat better. There are tons of videos on Youtube if you are curious.

sgift • Jan 21, 2015 • View on HN

May I recommend iron or copper pans? No sticking, can be used for your whole life. This new structure still looks nice.

maukdaddy • Aug 9, 2010 • View on HN

Actually a nice cast-iron pan would be better.

lukevp • Oct 31, 2024 • View on HN

Use a carbon steel or cast iron pan and learn how to season properly. They are very nonstick if you cook correctly in them, and their surface is incredibly durable (I use metal spatulas and I primarily cook on carbon steel and a cast iron griddle.) you can also incorporate stainless steel pots, although stainless pans are not nonstick and very hard to use for beginners.