Own vs Foreign Surveillance Fears

The cluster centers on debates about whether individuals, especially US citizens, should fear surveillance and data access by their own government (e.g., NSA) more than by foreign governments like China (e.g., CCP), with many arguing domestic spying poses greater risks due to direct power over citizens.

➡️ Stable 0.7x Security
3,508
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#8190
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
2
2008
3
2009
11
2010
30
2011
39
2012
71
2013
478
2014
195
2015
176
2016
240
2017
190
2018
172
2019
263
2020
334
2021
256
2022
288
2023
235
2024
184
2025
321
2026
22

Keywords

e.g USG US HN freebeacon.com ID ByteDance FBI YouTube TA government spying china nsa chinese foreign citizen ccp privacy spy

Sample Comments

ttflee Dec 2, 2016 View on HN

No, but at least US is not likely to leak some random personal info to non-allied government, e.g. China in this case, on purpose. It is neither legal nor preferable for the U.S. government to do so, I guess. And it might also be probable for an U.S. citizen to feel safer under the surveillance of an opponent of U.S., if not by the U.S. simultaneously.

syshum Oct 12, 2017 View on HN

I have always found this fear over "foreign states" to be a bit odd. Sure if you are a International Company, or a US Government Contractor it might be a concern but for me a Natural Born US Citizen that rarely if ever travels abroad and never to the nations of China or Russia I have limited reasons to fear those nation states, sure they could steal my ID and cause me some momentary financial harm but the US government is empowered to put me in a cage, physically harm me or even kill

ateeqs Nov 1, 2013 View on HN

Realize that it's probably just not the US government that has this type of access.

dictum Aug 9, 2013 View on HN

I'd be discussing on HN if a shadowy entity suddenly put a backdoor on a service I run to watch my customers' actions within the app.And I'm still very much annoyed that, as a foreigner who happens to have American customers and business partners, I'm told I have no reason to worry if the USG is watching my work, my personal activities and my relationships. I'd be just as annoyed if another entity was doing the spying and the posterior use of the information to punish

zogrodea Jan 24, 2024 View on HN

I don't understand this comment because American/European governments (where I would guess most HN commenters are from) are almost certainly doing the same thing according to what we've learned about for example the NSA. Maybe you trust your own government more.

cscurmudgeon Jun 20, 2023 View on HN

This is the answer to folks in the US saying: "I am not worried about a foreign govt. having my data"

AnimalMuppet Aug 14, 2015 View on HN

I don't trust my (US) government not to spy on me. But I don't trust the Chinese or Russian government not to spy on me, either. I'm not sure that they have my interest at heart any more than my own government does, and maybe less.

aurareturn Jan 12, 2026 View on HN

If you're a US citizen, it's far safer for the CCP to be spying on you than the US government.

o_p Aug 17, 2019 View on HN

Eh better be spied by the goverment in the other side of the world than in yours.

ok_dad Jan 7, 2022 View on HN

Not really an option; when the government wants something they’re basically your enemy. Who cares if China knows everything about me, they can’t get to me, whereas the USA government just has to issue some legal threat and I can’t stop it. China isn’t my enemy and can’t do shit to me. The USA gov might be someday.