School Discipline Overreach

Comments discuss criticisms of harsh school punishments, zero-tolerance policies, administrative overreactions, and overreach into off-campus student behavior, often sharing personal stories of unfair suspensions or expulsions.

📉 Falling 0.4x Politics & Society
5,393
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#8116
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
3
2008
15
2009
61
2010
154
2011
93
2012
158
2013
386
2014
147
2015
404
2016
190
2017
177
2018
173
2019
460
2020
279
2021
674
2022
535
2023
595
2024
449
2025
434
2026
6

Keywords

US LGBTQ CIA reddit.com USA CRT E.g school schools administrators kids kid students behavior kids school gesture speech

Sample Comments

markhorus Jul 5, 2023 View on HN

"in school suspension" is largely a US only thing

beaeglebeachh Apr 25, 2024 View on HN

Wait till the kids figure out how to do it. Principal at my school tried to have me expelled, by lying saying I was inciting violence. Soon it will be easy for kids to turn the tables on these tyrannical administrators in their insular fiefdoms.

soperj Sep 20, 2023 View on HN

Because people can control what their kids do at school...

VirusNewbie Apr 18, 2024 View on HN

Do they investigate public schools that engage in similar behavior???

molsongolden Aug 14, 2024 View on HN

This sounds similar to a small private school in the USA. Public schools here do not allow or enable discipline or the backing of the school.

mordocai Sep 16, 2015 View on HN

What I have heard from similar cases previously is that in a school you basically have no rights. Previous cases the school has been determined to be within their legal rights when doing things like this(including involving the police). I don't know much more than that though.

elzbardico Sep 11, 2025 View on HN

Jesus! those folks need to leave their kids alone! they are at school!

giantg2 Sep 22, 2024 View on HN

"Something's shifted with how schools enforce (or don't enforce) these policies"This is it. The other parts are tangential to the true cause.

burfog Nov 19, 2019 View on HN

We pretty much banned teachers from removing kids from school. We decided that every kid has the right to be in school, mostly in the normal classrooms.You can see the result.Basically, every tool for controlling bad behavior gets labeled "abuse" and banned. We don't seem to notice that the resulting disaster of an environment is abusive to the good kids.

agent008t Oct 10, 2019 View on HN

There is something very wrong with the school (system) if you actually got expelled for that. If that is the whole story, they should have explained why it was wrong and tried to encourage you to learn more, responsibly, by actually asking you to help them with securing their system. That is roughly what my headmaster in Russia did in similar circumstances. The thought of expelling a kid over something silly like this wouldn't even cross anyone's mind.