Type 1 vs Type 2 Diabetes

The cluster centers on debates distinguishing Type 1 (autoimmune, insulin-dependent) from Type 2 (often diet-related) diabetes, correcting misconceptions about causes, treatments like diet or insulin devices, and their applicability.

📉 Falling 0.3x Health
2,976
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#8071
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
12
2009
16
2010
28
2011
36
2012
49
2013
61
2014
87
2015
110
2016
158
2017
230
2018
315
2019
226
2020
233
2021
263
2022
270
2023
300
2024
397
2025
175
2026
10

Keywords

e.g II US tink.uk org.uk upi.com B.S www.ncl www.cnbc HN diabetes type diet insulin sugar blood carb weight disease interventions

Sample Comments

AlisdairO May 11, 2012 View on HN

My wife is a type 1 diabetic. Type 1 diabetes is a disorder not caused by diet or by any particular moral failing you might imagine, and people with it are the primary target of a device like this.Your ignorance is insulting to millions of people who suffer due to diabetes. Please educate yourself rather than spouting nonsense.

lolc Feb 8, 2019 View on HN

You mean diabetes type 2.It's tiring to keep getting suggestions of how to change diet when my body absolutely needs insulin from an external source. Further, while people may be able to reverse type 2, they still need insulin until they actually get there. So research into insulin delivery is relevant to all diabetics.Also there are many ways of reducing carbohydrate intake. The diet you write about is just one of many ways to do that. Why single it out?

shralpmeister Jun 18, 2012 View on HN

I'm type 2.Just to clarify, I'm not selling notions of curing type 1 diabetes through diet. If you're type 1 you will need insulin. Even type 2 may require insulin.The point I'm trying to make is that in both diseases (type 1 and 2) control of blood sugar is key to reducing mortality. Reducing carb intake will result in lower blood sugar rises which will require less insulin to counter. Less insulin means less chance of hypoglycemic events. By minimizing these control inputs you can balanc

osrec Feb 8, 2019 View on HN

Can anyone shed some light on why this can only help type 2 and not type 1 diabetics?

NotHereNotThere Jun 20, 2020 View on HN

He never mentioned it being a cure to T1D..

templaedhel Feb 8, 2019 View on HN

Can't speak to the claims in this comment around type 2 diabetes, but worth noting this article and pill is specifically for type 1 diabetes, which is in no way related to weight or metabolism, but rather an autoimmune disease.

RobertRoberts Jun 21, 2018 View on HN

Just saw this, may be relevant:https://www.cnbc.com/2018/06/20/diabetes-defeated-by-diet-ne...

shiftoutbox Feb 8, 2019 View on HN

No that can help with Type 2 diabetes only Not Type 1, or 1.5 ( A/k/a Flatbush Diabetes). The rest of the posters are talking about Type 1 or t1d, which is currently an incurable reaction to a yet unidentified pathogen . Your body attacks and destroies the pancreases ability to create insulin. The current method of management of T1D take synthetic insulin, insulin extracted from pigs , or genetically engineered insulin , check your blood sugar. Limit what you eat to limit how much in

philip1209 Nov 30, 2018 View on HN

Type II diabetes is a diet-related illness. If you cure the illness with diet, then switch back to what you were eating before - of course, diabetes will come back. These dietary changes need to be seen as new habits, not temporary changes.

Havoc Jul 30, 2021 View on HN

Maybe they just want to save them from diabetes