Public Transit vs Cars

Users debate the speed, convenience, comfort, and practicality of public transportation compared to driving cars, often contrasting experiences in dense European cities like London and Paris with those in US cities.

πŸ“‰ Falling 0.4x Politics & Society
3,779
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#800
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
1
2008
5
2009
20
2010
35
2011
46
2012
59
2013
84
2014
97
2015
135
2016
202
2017
297
2018
341
2019
429
2020
198
2021
249
2022
380
2023
480
2024
383
2025
331
2026
9

Keywords

e.g PROBABLY US LA JFK DC MC LIC AND BART car transit train minutes public transit bus city public transport public transport

Sample Comments

shawabawa3 β€’ Jul 31, 2022 β€’ View on HN

You just haven't lived in a city with good public transportIn e.g. London or Paris public transport is almost always the fastest way to get from A to B

tech_ken β€’ Jul 24, 2023 β€’ View on HN

Because it can get you to a location substantially faster than by car, in a way that doesn't require you to waste all your time and attention driving? The US has bent over backwards to accommodate cars and we're still seeing astronomical traffic during peak hours in all major metro areas. When they're built well, a train (or any public transit) ride can you to and from your place of work in an equal or shorter amount of time, while allowing you the freedom to do whatever you want

estaseuropano β€’ Sep 26, 2021 β€’ View on HN

Is that a problem of public transport in general or just of the public transport available to you? In most European cities e.g. buses have separate lanes and go every 10 minutes bringing you often faster to your destination than a private car can, not even counting the cost and time burden of finding parking, maintaining your car, insurance, ...It all depends on your local context, but where I live there is great and cheap transport and if I have a need for a car I can get one from stations

jakeogh β€’ Apr 13, 2018 β€’ View on HN

I can get anywhere in my local city in the time it takes me to jump in my car and drive there. Comparing that with walking to a bus stop and waiting for it to get near my destination is not even remotely close, _and I wouldn't want to even if it was faster_. Talking about speed (while important) ignores the ability to instantly change your plan.Your experience might work in a closely spaced situation (hence your odd comparison of moving at a magnitude difference velocity), where most peo

kjkjadksj β€’ Apr 1, 2023 β€’ View on HN

Honestly travel times on transit are bad everywhere. Its hard to beat the car, which is essentially a bus that goes express door to door to your destination, and can leave when you want. People take the alternative only when they can’t afford to take the car in regularly (e.g. bridge tolls and high parking costs in nyc ensure mainly high income people enjoy the convenience of a car). Even if you lived just 15 mins walking from a train station, thats a half hour added to every trip just getting b

jan_g β€’ Jan 2, 2020 β€’ View on HN

It is (almost) the same for every city, if you compare driving times from suburbs to city centre. The reason is that city train/metro/tram needs to stop on 15+ stations before reaching the inner city.Still, to me, train is superior - I can just sit and relax. Driving is much more tiring. 15 minutes or so difference is not worth it.

rahimnathwani β€’ Apr 26, 2021 β€’ View on HN

In London, public transportation is usually faster than driving (except during early morning or late night) for most journeys. You can get close to most places you'd want to go, without needing a car for the last mile.In Beijing, cars are faster for many journeys, and public transportation doesn't quite reach everywhere you'd want to go, without a lot of changes. But the reach and density of public transportation (particularly the subway system) is growing fast. And the last mi

nerfhammer β€’ Feb 15, 2020 β€’ View on HN

er, what? the NYC subway for example is vastly faster than driving.

thehappypm β€’ Dec 10, 2021 β€’ View on HN

I use public transit every day, I love it. I used to live in a city with a light rail system 2 blocks away. Even with that, I would still find it easier to drive and park downtown due to the delays, congestion, and slowness of the light rail line. Walk 5 minutes, wait 5 minutes, cram on, take 20 minute ride, walk 5 minutes VS 15 minute drive. Public transit needs to be either faster or cheaper than driving and it rarely is.

blibble β€’ Aug 21, 2025 β€’ View on HN

my public transport is faster and cheaper than driving...