Police Tracking Data Abuse

Comments discuss law enforcement's access to and potential misuse of location tracking data from devices like AirTags, raising concerns about illegal surveillance, privacy violations, and policy non-compliance.

📉 Falling 0.5x Legal
3,141
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#7901
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
3
2009
26
2010
42
2011
62
2012
72
2013
216
2014
161
2015
175
2016
192
2017
160
2018
208
2019
283
2020
248
2021
316
2022
246
2023
277
2024
206
2025
231
2026
17

Keywords

ZZZ ISP US FB news.html NCIC freenetproject.org wikipedia.org Amazon.com FBI police law enforcement information enforcement data law flock investigation cops cell phone

Sample Comments

spacemanmatt • Mar 28, 2022 • View on HN

Sounds like another way for cops to launder illegally obtained information.

upsidesinclude • Sep 2, 2022 • View on HN

You missed the part where they illegally used private data to ascertain every individual in the area.Then cross reference et cetera.There was the illegal part, at the beginning. The police could have just put in the effort and checking on information from various channels, determined the same information. However, that requires effort and occasionally intelligent actors. So, instead, they do the illegal part, scrub that from the record, and pretend they figured it out, with a pencil and a

cute_boi • Oct 8, 2020 • View on HN

if there is no PII to connect then there is nothing for cops to find?

sroussey • Jan 3, 2021 • View on HN

Yes, it keeps randoms out. Be careful asking friends in law enforcement to look something up for you. Requests are logged. And if another law enforcement group has an alert set, you will get a visit asking why you were asking.

alphabettsy • Nov 23, 2020 • View on HN

No issue then since the government and police especially have a good track record of following policies and rules that’s aren’t the law. /sOnly be able to access it when a crime occurs how? They’ll get a warrant or an officer says a crime occurred and asks for access?

rmrfrmrf • Feb 27, 2018 • View on HN

Sounds like a great side-channel attack vector for law enforcement.

mortenjorck • Dec 19, 2021 • View on HN

I have a feeling the interaction with the police in a lot of jurisdictions would go something like:“This person at this address tried to track me without my consent! Here’s the documentation from Apple!”“Ma’am, has the person at this address murdered you?”“No.”“I’m afraid there’s nothing we can do right now. If this person does murder you, please call 911 immediately.”

guelo • Oct 27, 2015 • View on HN

It is illegal but cops don't care because they want the same data. Time for a massive class action lawsuit.

jimmywanger • Mar 18, 2017 • View on HN

Most law enforcement actions are predicated on circumstantial evidence.We already provide such information, which is completely legal.For instance, if there's a pipe bomb, police track down the list of people who've bought ingredients from the bomb (from retailers, cell phone companies) and other sources of information to narrow down the list of probable suspects.The Boston bombers were caught by such techniques. I don't see why this is any different.

tsukurimashou • Dec 18, 2019 • View on HN

it is probably possible to collect that on police cars but I suspect police has access to it, so not very useful