Movie Enjoyment Debate

Discussions revolve around why and how people enjoy movies, contrasting mindless entertainment and storytelling with artistic appreciation, amid complaints about declining attention spans and modern film quality.

📉 Falling 0.3x Other
4,180
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#790
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
2
2008
13
2009
49
2010
76
2011
77
2012
114
2013
134
2014
98
2015
164
2016
149
2017
196
2018
235
2019
306
2020
219
2021
458
2022
578
2023
555
2024
374
2025
369
2026
14

Keywords

GP BETTER YouTube MORE TV wikipedia.org movies movie film enjoy watching watch trailer artistic enjoyment films

Sample Comments

tbrownaw Jan 31, 2025 View on HN

Not even for mindless entertainment?

pests Feb 18, 2024 View on HN

Not everyone watchs a film for intellectual pursuits, some just want to enjoy a story or relax and unwind.

barrkel Jun 10, 2016 View on HN

Different people enjoy different things. Not all people are like you.I appreciate good film-making as an exercise in light and shadow, cutting and camera movement, sound and vision. But most pop movies are not made like that; they're mechanically constructed with all the art of a fast food meal. The only payoff they have is their short story, and it takes so little hinting to make it too obvious.I'm not a fan of any actor in particular. I don't go to see a movie because an a

catshirt Oct 29, 2015 View on HN

you nailed it. i didn't have the patience to try to articulate this. it's an unfamiliar medium for telling a story, and it's freaking people out.just sounds so hypocritical and old fashioned to consider this tasteless or immoral. you're all starting to sound like your parents.

evilfred Feb 6, 2025 View on HN

you completely misunderstand what it means to enjoy a film experience.

slibhb Dec 29, 2022 View on HN

You don't have to intellectualize movies to enjoy them.

lofaszvanitt Apr 11, 2025 View on HN

People watch films for the experience, for the stimulation, and to be able to relive that exact experience at any time if they need to. So all this generative nonsense is just bullshit wrapped up in shiny packaging.

lleb97a Mar 13, 2022 View on HN

Could it be we are use to media/news reporting so we struggle with movies?

So many movies are going to don't make sense anymore but it's about time we are anyway going to come to a world where we need to find amusement in something else

asdff Dec 10, 2018 View on HN

Have you considered that nothing really changed with how much attention people give to movies? You are only looking at your friend's behavior, and assuming that the story would change if you lived in another decade. You can't rule out that even in the days where movies were only shown in a theater, that maybe 10% of the audience was paying enough attention to truly appreciate the film and not distracted with other thoughts. Being an active and engaged watcher is difficult work, and it