GPA Job Performance Correlation

Comments debate the predictive power of academic credentials like GPA, degrees, and SAT scores for job success, often citing Google studies showing weak or no correlations and favoring alternatives like work samples and IQ.

📉 Falling 0.3x Career & Jobs
1,185
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#7782
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
8
2008
18
2009
37
2010
20
2011
45
2012
36
2013
71
2014
56
2015
91
2016
76
2017
94
2018
80
2019
93
2020
70
2021
78
2022
121
2023
79
2024
52
2025
58
2026
2

Keywords

IQ US deal.html GPA financialpost.com businessinsider.com PQ MBA SAT HR gpa performance iq job correlation interview predictive predictor success grades

Sample Comments

starpilot Feb 15, 2020 View on HN

Google has strong data that it does predict job performance, better than GPA, college degree and so on. What are your aggregate data showing that Google is wrong on this?

alphazard Jan 24, 2023 View on HN

The best way to see if someone will perform well at a job, is to have them do that job and see. The second best way is to ask them for proof they succeeded at a similar job. That proof is usually a combination of references and a discussion about work they did at the previous job.If you can't do any of those things, like for some recent grads, then the next best predictors of job performance are going to be psychometrics, specifically IQ and trait conscientiousness. Colleges heavily s

mountainriver Apr 19, 2022 View on HN

Do SAT scores correspond with work performance?

usaar333 Dec 3, 2014 View on HN

Agreed. The study is showing how much people's views of resume X agrees with the author's full evaluation.But what I or my company consider a quality candidate may differ from the author.On another note, I've found that for recent grads, GPA, school, and major (all items on the resume) are excellent predictors of interview performance.

Alex3917 Jun 7, 2009 View on HN

"A company looking for new hires can't give everyone a month-long trial to see what their ability is firsthand, so credentials like GPA and degree serve as a heuristic."This is just corporate propaganda. GPA has no correlation with work performance, it's only used because it's a legal way to keep minorities out of the workforce.

pvillano May 27, 2021 View on HN

not only that, but they aren't a great predictor of actual job performance

reader5000 Oct 29, 2010 View on HN

Eh, do quote fairly though:"Although GPA has been widely analyzed, the research has produced inconsistent results. Some meta-analyses suggest that grades have relatively low validity as a predictor of job success (Bretz, 1989; Hunter and Hunter, 1984). Individual studies by Ferris (1982) and Schick and Kunnecke (1982) support the meta-analysis findings; these studies found no relationship between grades and performance evaluations."In other words the state of research on this question, bac

kenjackson Jan 9, 2011 View on HN

Meta data analysis from thousands of studies shows that there is essentially 0 correlation between where someone went to school (or their GPA) and how well they perform on the job once hiredThe data may say that, but it likely omits a lot.For example, if I have a candidate with straight A's from MIT, but I hire someone else who had a 1.2 from Podunk State instead, I supsect that the candidate from Podunk State had some other qualification that offset their school and GPA.This is

ultramancool Aug 25, 2016 View on HN

Sure, 'smarter' was a poor choice of words, but the point is I suspect there may be a correlation between general cognitive performance and job attainment.

cm2012 Mar 16, 2023 View on HN

Work sample tests and IQ are the only thing in the whole hiring song and dance that correlate to future performance. And it's legally questionable to test IQ.