European vs US Cities

Discussions compare the historical evolution, adaptability, and walkable density of European cities like Paris and Amsterdam to car-optimized American urban designs, debating planned renovations versus organic growth.

📉 Falling 0.4x Politics & Society
2,712
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#7654
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
16
2009
17
2010
27
2011
26
2012
46
2013
78
2014
80
2015
123
2016
170
2017
138
2018
261
2019
220
2020
254
2021
243
2022
297
2023
261
2024
256
2025
190
2026
9

Keywords

US USSR wikipedia.org YIMBY en.m wordpress.com cmu.edu graphics.cs BC WWII cities city planned paris european streets build buildings cities like roman

Sample Comments

the8472 Jul 11, 2018 View on HN

A comparison to old european cities would be interesting.

apexalpha Apr 30, 2019 View on HN

Entire cities are historic in Europe. You don't need glass and steel towers to cope with growth. Just build more densely populated suburbs and have good public transport infrastructure to connect people.

jjulius Dec 13, 2021 View on HN

Perhaps cities were initially planned with them in mind as opposed to in the US?

panick21_ Dec 9, 2023 View on HN

In places where humans have been a long town you simply dont create new cities. In a place like Switzerland I could imagine what that would even look like.There are villages everywhere, some grew and became small cities, some slighly larger and do on.Founding city only happens if you move lots of people into a lightly lived in area or during a massive population boom due to agroculture.And you dont need new cities to build great infrastrucute. Look at Istanbul. One of the oldest cities

downrightmike Feb 27, 2024 View on HN

Just build a european city copy, thousands of years of human living have already figured out how we want to live

If your city is like every other in the US, they changed drastically. Find a city map from pre WWII and compare it to today.

davidw Aug 7, 2021 View on HN

Cities are pretty adaptable, no need to build one from scratch. Look at how Amsterdam changed, or how Paris is changing now

Derbasti Apr 22, 2012 View on HN

Look at Europe or Asia: All them old cities were designed without cars. Actually, many European cities today opt for car-free downtown areas.

pergadad Dec 21, 2019 View on HN

Same in Europe. Brussels city in the 1900s moved 20.000 families to build a single street (now the main pedestrian area). Mussolini paved over dozens of ancient Roman sites to build a big street through the city centre. Paris went through an entire planned effort to reshape the whole city, which created all the famous avenues you know today and at the same time created all the social problems (poor 'banlieue' areas around the city) we still know and love today.

wolverine876 Dec 14, 2021 View on HN

Many cities are planned. Paris was planned in the 19th century, after it had been around for millenia, and they tore stuff down and rebuilt it.