Books vs Online Reading

The cluster centers on debates about the value and effectiveness of reading books versus consuming short-form online content like Hacker News articles, often referencing 'Why Books Don't Work' by Andy Matuschak and books like 'How to Read a Book'.

πŸ“‰ Falling 0.4x Other
5,303
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#7614
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
19
2008
62
2009
91
2010
131
2011
137
2012
135
2013
136
2014
138
2015
185
2016
235
2017
272
2018
316
2019
441
2020
624
2021
453
2022
494
2023
544
2024
452
2025
414
2026
24

Keywords

andymatuschak.org YC i.e ALP UK HCE ycombinator.com NYC fs.blog wikipedia.org books reading read book read book reading books read books want read books read article

Sample Comments

miguelrochefort β€’ May 5, 2019 β€’ View on HN

I spend 6-10 hours a day binge reading Hacker News, Reddit, Google search results, etc. Is it qualitatively different than reading books? Am I missing out? I feel like books are expensive, repetitive, and take forever to get to the point.

segh β€’ Jul 29, 2021 β€’ View on HN

You might be interested in Why Books Don't Work by Andy Matuschakhttps://andymatuschak.org/books/

privacyonsec β€’ Dec 18, 2021 β€’ View on HN

Why books don't work : https://andymatuschak.org/books/

npsimons β€’ Apr 7, 2014 β€’ View on HN

It's been said before[1] and I'll say it again: some things aren't worth your full reading attention. Heck, even if they were, you don't have enough time to read everything[2].That being said, I am a little worried that people (at least myself) aren't getting as "deep" into topics as they might have used to. I try to solve this by (very carefully!) picking books that I can slowly digest, over multiple readings. If nothing else, just reading them at the inspe

book-sandworm β€’ Sep 22, 2020 β€’ View on HN

Couldn't get through the whole article to be honest. Started kicking open doors. That made me scroll to the conclusion. Which was also underwhelming.Reading the books he mentioned, I'm reading them not to know everything word by word. I'm reading them to get a map of that topic. One that would guide me to a narrower source if needed.To even get more Meta, let's be honest. Blog like this are not really written for the readers. They are written because the author likes th

0x262d β€’ Jan 5, 2020 β€’ View on HN

I'm sorry that you have viewed books this way for at least ten years. Deeper treatment of a given topic or story necessarily takes a long time to explain and the format of longform text exposition is called a book. They are worth reading. Also many are timeless, most problems are not new. Please read books and focus at first on books considered to be timeless classics. It sounds like you will be pleasantly surprised. I expect this will enrich your life a lot in ways you probably don't

jacobolus β€’ Mar 3, 2010 β€’ View on HN

> daily "aha" moments, that i cant get from books at this frequency.You’re reading the wrong books.

mohoromitch β€’ Nov 28, 2021 β€’ View on HN

I personally think that it goes deeper than just the ability to read and absorb. You to ask, and understand the motivations _for_ reading something, otherwise it's going to feel like a chore. I just finished "How to Take Smart Notes" and it seriously changed how I view readings like this. Where it's not for a short term gain, but rather an incremental increase in my knowledge base.The content may not be super relevant immediately, but the book and (really simple) methodolo

soapdog β€’ Jan 4, 2020 β€’ View on HN

I'm 39 years old and books have been an integral part of how I define myself as a human. I grew up with books and they've been a constant presence in my life regardless of what I was doing. It is my personal belief that there is no substitute for good books. By books I don't mean the paper medium, I mean long form narrative that you can absorb and revisit on your own time, it could be eBooks, paper books, audio books are a bit trickier for me but they do fit my own personal criter

ritchiea β€’ Jan 4, 2020 β€’ View on HN

First of all no one remembers everything they read. If you spend time reading lots of books you will find things that stick out to you personally that you are surprised other people didn't bring up in the summaries you are accustomed to hearing elsewhere. You'll also find yourself disagreeing with other people's summaries and interpretations of books you've read.So yes, I would say reading books is worth it. And the best way to start is for now is put aside your "must