Building New Cities

The cluster revolves around debates on the feasibility of building new cities from scratch versus organic growth, critiques of urban planning, density issues, and why planned cities often fail.

📉 Falling 0.3x Politics & Society
4,545
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#7580
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
3
2009
28
2010
46
2011
54
2012
61
2013
82
2014
104
2015
194
2016
350
2017
384
2018
363
2019
449
2020
308
2021
519
2022
544
2023
447
2024
355
2025
243
2026
11

Keywords

US PHX IMO YC SLC DC AC AND SF i.e cities city urban building planned suburbs sprawl organically buildings live

Sample Comments

amelius Jul 2, 2020 View on HN

Won't work. Most popular cities today have grown organically, and were not designed by a small number of people.

ivanca Jul 8, 2013 View on HN

Yes, many big cities are (state-sponsored) trying to grow vertically instead of horizontally.

galfarragem Jun 27, 2016 View on HN

Architect here.New cities normally don't work as expected: cities are like a living organism, they need time to mature. Lots of research was already made on these subjects (most people are not aware of it) and even if some ideas are really good, status quo makes any change very difficult.By the other hand the knowledge fronteer is still near on building cities in different environments/planets, so IMO, YC should go on that direction instead.

cimmanom Nov 7, 2018 View on HN

Aren't we talking about urban settings? Building cities from scratch?

self_awareness Apr 23, 2024 View on HN

Building a city seems very... central planned. Normally these things should grow organically. Unless maybe you're in China or North Korea.

timeon Feb 28, 2024 View on HN

Yes, bad urban planning is problem.

pzo Jan 16, 2026 View on HN

you don't have to build new city from scratch just do city planning and dedicate one outside part of city to high density, high tower residential buildings then let me people decide where they want to live.

adrianN Jul 10, 2018 View on HN

So? That's a result of city planning that could have happened in the US as well.

Nasrudith Jul 19, 2019 View on HN

I have noticed that the main failing of planned cities seems to be the megalomania and misguided sense of organization trying to decide how it will be used specifically - often out of some misguided ideal of efficiency instead of leaving it to the people to decide. It brings to mind having a single restuarant outside every cul de sac and expecting residents to go only for the nearest restaurant.Sanity calls for embracing the non-deteminism. Wall Street wasn't intended as a world financia

mupuff1234 Nov 1, 2021 View on HN

Why aren't countries building new cities?