Brendan Eich Mozilla Resignation

The cluster discusses Brendan Eich's resignation as Mozilla CEO after his donation to Prop 8 opposing gay marriage, debating free speech, discrimination, corporate leadership, and Mozilla's commitment to inclusivity and freedom.

📉 Falling 0.5x Politics & Society
2,585
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#7398
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
1
2009
1
2010
1
2011
2
2012
16
2013
12
2014
1,261
2015
189
2016
142
2017
134
2018
80
2019
78
2020
245
2021
106
2022
77
2023
102
2024
51
2025
82
2026
5

Keywords

e.g US DO HQ OK SF PR NRA CEO GMO eich mozilla gay marriage ceo gay marriage prop rights employees support

Sample Comments

lern_too_spel Apr 8, 2014 View on HN

It's interesting that you use the euphemism "political opinion" for oppression. The reason this was an issue for Mozilla was not because people have strongly held views on carbon permits vs. carbon taxes but because Eich went out of his way to help take rights away from an already oppressed group. This is truly disgusting behavior that many people (not just gays) rightfully wanted to distance themselves from. The fact that Mozilla draws most of its contributors from progressive en

A1kmm Mar 30, 2014 View on HN

The Mozilla Foundation (and Corporation) are in a difficult position here, because they are being blamed for someone else doing something unethical, but it would also be unethical for them to do (or have done) anything differently in response to it.Brendan Eich's behaviour in 2008 in trying to take the choice away from couples to marry just because they happen not to be straight is a despicable step to interfere with the rights of others. His apology this month (<a href="https://brendane

recibe Feb 5, 2015 View on HN

For the record, I want nothing to do with Mozilla after what happened to Brendan Eich.And to you little nazis that downvote this:ANYONE who thinks its just to remove a CEO because of their personal beliefs on same-sex marriage is no better than anyone else who "discriminates" for any other reason.

strongsauce Mar 26, 2014 View on HN

I am very confused by the different signals the javascript community continues to send about this situation compared to others. On the one hand, people continually get shouted down for saying or doing things that are offensive or insensitive to minority groups (and rightly so), however a lot of the same people seem to give Eich a lot of slack and choose to consider this situation as not a big deal.I do not know the Eich, and I am not gay, so the only thing I can compare it to is as someone wh

camus2 Apr 3, 2014 View on HN

First, i want to say to Eich,that he is entitled to his opinions and noone is going to go after him with pitchforks and torches for that.Next, I believe that was the right decision. Because it put Mozilla into a difficult position. You might think all this anger was excessive perhaps it was, yet it casted a negative image on Mozilla,since the CEO is a public figure for a company.I hope this event will open up a real debate about gay rights and why it equal rights matter, because more right

pko722 Oct 18, 2016 View on HN

Sigh. People keep bringing up Brendan Eich. What happened there is very simple: a good chunk of Mozilla PR and marketing is about freedom. Software and online freedom, yes, but the word "freedom" is used a fair bit. Eich monetarily supported a cause that aimed to take away freedom for a certain class of people. This is incongruent for the face of an organization that has freedom one of its core messages.Mozilla is fairly unique in tech world in this regard. Nearly all other companie

Karunamon May 13, 2015 View on HN

I again challenge you to provide me with a single shred of evidence that in his 16 years at Mozilla Eich treated even one member of the LGBT community unfairly from his position of power.But again, we're not worried about Eich's impact on Mozilla, which was, as you say, positive. I don't think he did abuse his power or hurt anybody by his actions at Mozilla - at least not from the 90's to 08 which is when the first inkling of his views became public.More i

lern_too_spel Sep 5, 2017 View on HN

Nobody looked into Eich's voting record. Eich donated to a campaign against gay marriage, and donations above a certain threshold are public record. Gay people and people who support civil rights who are strong enough coders to work for Mozilla will easily find employment at any of a number of other Bay Area employers run by people who support them. Mozilla was losing developers[1], and Eich took the reasonable action of stepping down instead of destroying his organization. You can imagine

wfo Jun 19, 2015 View on HN

Politics are always a factor in every industry and every facet of life, it is naive to think otherwise, politics are what happens when a large enough group of people have to be led, be it in a company or a country.As far as Eich is concerned there are three things to keep in mind: 1) He was the public face of the company, he was supposed to represent Mozilla's values; there was NO problem with Eich when he was an engineer or simple employee of the company 2) It was a non-profit dedicated

cookiecaper May 3, 2014 View on HN

* Marriage is not a constitutional right for anyone* The rules that say the government is not allowed to define marriage further than "two humans say they want to live together and want us to give them stuff for it" are very new, and Eich was fighting to not have this become the rule.* Gay people should be perfectly comfortable working for people who supported Prop 8 or they're going to have a hard time, as there's a > 50% chance that a random stranger will have done