Salary Supply and Demand

Discussions argue that employee pay is determined by labor market supply and demand dynamics, scarcity of skills, and bargaining power rather than the individual value created or effort expended.

📉 Falling 0.2x Career & Jobs
4,179
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#7354
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
8
2008
21
2009
27
2010
54
2011
100
2012
120
2013
154
2014
185
2015
213
2016
263
2017
334
2018
292
2019
322
2020
443
2021
468
2022
370
2023
405
2024
215
2025
177
2026
8

Keywords

IQ e.g i.e MUCH supply demand market demand supply salary paid pay labor value labor market

Sample Comments

twblalock Dec 29, 2019 View on HN

It is about supply and demand in the labor market, full stop. People aren't paid based on the value they create. They are paid based on how hard it is to find other people who can do the same thing.

ukoki Jul 2, 2020 View on HN

People are paid based on how much a similarly skilled worker is willing to work for, not based on how much value they generate for a company.

rayiner Sep 10, 2013 View on HN

Why does Economics 101 go out the window when it comes to labor supply and demand? Rising prices increase supply until supply and demand reach equilibrium. The "sustainable salary expense" is whatever the market decides it is. Remember, prices affect the demand curve too. The specter of businesses not being able to afford labor is wholly fictional. If the market price of programmers is $300k and some businesses cannot afford nurses at $300k, that doesn't mean there is anything wro

damoncali Nov 13, 2011 View on HN

People are paid in proportion to how hard they are to hire and retain. End of story.

prepend Apr 4, 2023 View on HN

People are not paid based on their value. They are paid based on what the labor market drives. There’s some relationship to value, but it depends on how many people can and are willing to do the job.

Nevada-Smith Apr 28, 2020 View on HN

One is not paid what one is worth--rather, one is paid for what the job is worth.

steve_taylor Feb 15, 2020 View on HN

Pay is based on supply and demand economics, not fairness.

gambiting Mar 1, 2017 View on HN

Sure. But it's a supply and demand problem. It's hard to find a competent programmer, so you have to pay more to attract one, or they are going to work somewhere else. But it's easy to find someone to clean the floors, so even if you offer very low wage that is going to discourage some people, there will be others who will take it. It has nothing to do with value they provide.

kansface Jan 9, 2015 View on HN

Workers aren't paid based on their IQ, but on supply and demand.

msandford Mar 31, 2023 View on HN

A kinder way to say this is "the talent entering the market is pushing wages down" or something like that. It's pretty rare that wages reflect worth. They reflect what employers have to / are willing to pay.