HN Downvote Discussions
This cluster revolves around debates over why comments on Hacker News receive downvotes, including explanations of voting reasons like poor tone or low value, complaints about unfair downvoting, and defenses of downvoted opinions.
Activity Over Time
Top Contributors
Keywords
Sample Comments
I think you're getting downvoted because you're being snide about it, not because you stated the fact.
Wow. My heart-felt anecdote offended somebody. Down-votes don't contribute to the debate.
I think the down votes are for spouting nonsense instead of having a rational discussion about the article.
I think you're being downvoted because you chose to piggyback your comment on a seemingly unrelated one at the top, are being vitriolic, and didn't back up your claims with respect to their intent and refusal to change this.
I think you are being downvoted because there is little information in what you are saying.Off topic. Well known argument. Tone seems angry.Just a guess
People are downvoting you because you are making blanket generalizations that don’t meaningfully add to the conversation, and then doubling down on them when challenged. I thought maybe you would like to know what’s happening, but if it’s not wanted sorry to have potentially upset you further.
It's incredible that you've being down-voted.(I'm aware of the rules / norms and I'm deliberately breaking them here. Some things need to be called out.)
My goodness, why is this being downvoted? It's a rational presentation of an unpopular position, with some thought-provoking assertions of unintended side-effects: who here is punishing such comments?
Wow, you're literally being downvoted for just making an observation. Pretty sad for this community.
You made a benign claim about the article that was incorrect, and in the interest of not confusing other HNers your comment was downvoted, why are you taking this personally?