Nazi Holocaust Comparisons

This cluster centers on debates comparing contemporary issues, policies, or actions to Nazi atrocities, the Holocaust, genocide, and WWII events, often invoking Godwin's Law and questioning the validity or implications of such analogies.

➡️ Stable 0.7x Politics & Society
4,770
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#7243
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
3
2008
2
2009
46
2010
59
2011
50
2012
67
2013
173
2014
131
2015
207
2016
249
2017
321
2018
316
2019
350
2020
387
2021
508
2022
454
2023
471
2024
362
2025
580
2026
34

Keywords

NAZI II US HN WW2 E2 USSR wikipedia.org CECOT youtube.com holocaust nazi nazis germany camps ww2 poles concentration camps nazi germany genocide

Sample Comments

firebat45 Sep 18, 2023 View on HN

This is a WW2 topic so I feel okay with invoking Godwin's Law:This is the same excuse many Germans that took part in the concentration camps used. Turns out, still doesn't make genocide okay.

colejohnson66 Feb 10, 2021 View on HN

I was trying to avoid “Poe’s Law-ing” my comment, but Nazi genocide was exactly what I was thinking of. They (at least the higher ups) believed it was for the greater good, but the rest of the world (and history) has disagreed with them. So much so, we executed the higher ups during the trials afterwards.

smnscu Dec 17, 2016 View on HN

1st comment on the article> there are among even the most terrifying of targeted massacres such as during the regime of pol pot or the misery of rwanda nothing comparable to the holocaust. Jewish children were being hanged from windows in the neighborhoods of germans whose neighbors knew the families. the german people eagerly and happily enjoyed herr hitler and his band of sick psychopaths and perverts and lest we forget to mention it, drug addicts. those who stood against these crimes we

tscs37 Aug 18, 2017 View on HN

You should educate yourself because what you ask for is basically what happened to jews in the third reich. Not even something toned down or a "behind the curtains" deal, by doing this you are not better than the nazi's themselves, you stoop to their level.

ajuc Feb 9, 2015 View on HN

There's no question at all. It happened in many countries outside Germany, just with less publicity.For few pre-WW2 examples:Even Hitler refered to genocide of Armenians in Turkey http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armenian_GenocideJust before WW2 there was ethnic cleaning of Poles in USSR

quetzthecoatl Jun 10, 2023 View on HN

not just WW2, everything that lead to it, everything that the allies were involved in when WW2 was going on etc. I mean, most of the atrocities that the Nazis did were to the German Jews who were not part of the WW2 at all. Does this mean those doesn't count? This kind of logic stumps me.For the record, i responded your question almost instantly and HN didn't let me post. Got an error saying i am typing too fast.

teiferer Jan 18, 2026 View on HN

Those sterilized during Nazi rule would like a word.

Geminidog Feb 4, 2021 View on HN

It's very possible for everyone to be guilty. We don't live in a world where if something isn't "useful" it isn't true.Your statement ends up reading sort of like "Is every Nazi guilty of the holocaust?" Technically maybe not, doesn't change the fact that of the matter that overall all Nazis are guilty.You can't run away from this with some garbage statement of "Not a very useful perspective." This incident literally killed an amo

DrillShopper Apr 18, 2025 View on HN

> Hell, even Nazi Germany didn't last forever.How'd that work out for the millions slaughtered while the vast majority of the German population (who knew about the death camps) did nothing?I'm getting pretty sick of this twee bullshit about how "we've come back from worse!". No. Not all of us did. Stop it

rmc Nov 23, 2016 View on HN

Stopping another Holocaust or Nazi regime is not a good reason?