Videos vs Text Learning

Debate on the effectiveness of video tutorials versus text or written resources for technical and programming education, with criticisms of videos for lacking searchability, speed control, and accessibility, contrasted by defenses for engagement and visual explanations.

📉 Falling 0.4x Other
4,093
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#7122
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
9
2008
33
2009
88
2010
122
2011
245
2012
210
2013
179
2014
109
2015
148
2016
181
2017
178
2018
219
2019
223
2020
386
2021
389
2022
357
2023
383
2024
325
2025
283
2026
26

Keywords

HN ANY TED i.e MANY CC SymfonyCasts HTML RacketCon YouTube videos video watching watch text format tutorial youtube learn think needs

Sample Comments

mtogo Aug 22, 2011 View on HN

Some people learn better with videos. It doesn't have much to do with the subject matter.

enriquto Jun 25, 2018 View on HN

do you really watch these videos? It seems that video is a reallly bad format for such technical information. Much better would be plain text; or, if you want to be fancy, user-editable code snippets.

BiteCode_dev May 23, 2021 View on HN

You still need the explanation, videos are not accessible nor search engine friendly.It's a good complement though.

mattlondon Sep 29, 2019 View on HN

I hate videos for technical learning. I will avoid them as much as possible, especially if I cannot play at 2x speed (or more!) and/or if they don't have a thumbnail-preview when skipping.Often I find that with videos:- I already know some bits and pieces about something - it is quite rare to be coming in 100% fresh to something. So I don't want to have to sit through all the crap I already know, or have to skip backwards and forwards getting past the pre-amble ("What

pbreit Aug 21, 2011 View on HN

The video is definitely more engaging than text would have been. And I think it's a reasonable topic on HN. I knew some of it but certainly not all.

squigz Oct 18, 2024 View on HN

Not everyone likes watching videos.

contingencies Jul 19, 2013 View on HN

What's the point of video when programming? That's just a distraction.

antihero Sep 24, 2012 View on HN

Good for you, but please understand that there are others who learn much better with a video tutorial.

honkdaddy Sep 22, 2022 View on HN

Thanks for this. Seems like a topic better learned from a wiki article than a video.

luckylion Feb 9, 2020 View on HN

I find them valuable if you don't need to write code to experiment with but can just watch the video at the regular speed and get the concepts that you can then use in your project. Also allows for watching while you do other stuff on the side.SymfonyCasts is an example where I like the videos. They aren't the typical YouTube style of "let me talk about random things for 5 minutes so I get this video over the 10 minute mark", they get pretty much straight to the point. The