Savings vs Hoarding

This cluster debates whether saving money in bank accounts constitutes hoarding, emphasizing that deposits are lent out and invested in the economy rather than sitting idle like cash under a mattress.

📉 Falling 0.3x Finance & Crypto
3,839
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#702
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
2
2008
20
2009
55
2010
59
2011
87
2012
72
2013
175
2014
130
2015
180
2016
269
2017
243
2018
226
2019
349
2020
336
2021
542
2022
408
2023
296
2024
176
2025
205
2026
9

Keywords

TL www.npr DR McDuck USD NPR wikipedia.org money bank savings mattress inflation money bank account savings account cash hoarding

Sample Comments

tom_mellior Sep 5, 2019 View on HN

Money is not apples, money in a bank account doesn't rot. Why make it rot artificially? You don't explain.

WalterBright May 29, 2024 View on HN

Putting money in a bank is not hoarding it. The bank loans out the money to people who invest/spend it.

OstiaAntica Apr 17, 2011 View on HN

No one squirrels away money-- savings in a bank is still reinvested into the economy, by the bank through lending. Unless you are literally sticking money under a mattress, it gets circulated.

barry-cotter Mar 19, 2019 View on HN

Money that is not being spent is almost always being invested. If cash is literally being hoarded under a mattress it’s neither being spend nor invested but that means that the value of everyone else’s money goes up by some infinitesimal amount. If Bill Gates turned his entire fortune into cash and then set it on fire the assets that that cash used to represent would not disappear. Bill Gates would just have made all other holders of dollars a bit richer.

core-questions Feb 24, 2021 View on HN

Doesn't the "hoarding money" thing only even apply if you keep your money as literal physical cash in your mattress?If it's in a bank account, it's being lent out and is working, no?

lmkg Mar 21, 2019 View on HN

The proposition is not that people won't spend money. The proposition is that they won't invest the money that they're not spending. Keeping money under the mattress is not competing against groceries and Netflix, it's competing against government bonds and/or interest-bearing bank accounts.

bawana May 12, 2020 View on HN

there will be no inflation because the money is not being spent. It is being invested. As for savings, no sane person would put their money into a savings account. Why lend your money to the bank (if you even have any to spare)?!

missedthecue Mar 14, 2021 View on HN

If it's in a bank account, it's not being hoarded. It's being loaned out and the people who get the loans are spending it on houses, businesses, automobiles, etc...

jessaustin Jul 15, 2016 View on HN

Why don't they just put their money in a bank, or invest it?

imtringued Aug 13, 2021 View on HN

Btw don't save in money. Save in stocks or bonds. The banks don't need your money for loans.