Office Layout Preferences

Cluster focuses on personal experiences and debates comparing open office plans, cubicles, private offices, and small team rooms, discussing their impacts on productivity, collaboration, noise, and team dynamics.

📉 Falling 0.1x Career & Jobs
3,963
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#6549
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
8
2008
33
2009
36
2010
55
2011
66
2012
155
2013
300
2014
327
2015
372
2016
331
2017
490
2018
287
2019
336
2020
290
2021
201
2022
174
2023
346
2024
96
2025
52
2026
8

Keywords

e.g US WFH HN AND OPEN i.e RTO IN IBM office offices open office open private floor plan team headphones room

Sample Comments

squeaky-clean Jan 15, 2015 View on HN

I agree completely. I prefer the open office layout a hundred times over, compared to a private room or a cubicle. Maybe it depends on your coworkers, you have to trust them not to be too loud or bothersome, and you have to be fine with being in the same room as these people for 8+ hours a day for a long time.At my office, the "Dev Room" has 10 engineers in the same room, as well as open desks for anyone else to join us. The rest of the office has rooms with 1-3 people working in th

marmot1101 Mar 10, 2015 View on HN

I thrive in the small group office. You get the flow of ideas that are trying to be achieved with the open plan, but without as much of the noise. And it's easier to call out one or two people for being difficult to work with than it is many. I hated a private cube(big effin cube with high walls and all) because I felt like I was in solitary. Sometimes I want to bullshit about what I did over the weekend, or discuss a philisophical question about what I'm doing. Seems weird to pop

Ironlink Apr 19, 2015 View on HN

I currently work in an office made of small-ish rooms, each with 5 to 10 persons in an open floor plan. The people sharing a room are in the same team. I don't think I could go from this to having a private office, the cold and quiet loneliness would be depressing. I love the banter that comes up while waiting for a test suite to complete, and the ability to quickly do some pair programming or have an impromptu team meeting. At any time, we can simply turn around to face each other instead

lallysingh Mar 10, 2015 View on HN

I guess I'm in a real minority here, but I'm pretty happy with open-office.Some qualifiers:- The team has a good culture of respecting each other, and we're busy enough not to want to banter too much outside of certain times (e.g., lunch, when we see it already going on, etc.).- I've got good headphones hooked to a 24-bit-DAC'd USB amp. I don't hear anyone unless I'm trying to.- My screen's big enough where visual noise isn't an issue.

jesseryoung May 22, 2017 View on HN

It seems like when "Open Office" articles come out there seem to be quite a few people talking ill of them. I recently switched jobs and with it switched from an open concept (large room with whiteboards separating teams) to an office (shared with one other coworker.) Maybe I was conditioned to like it (I certainly didn't like it at first) but I really did prefer the open concept when working on a team of 8 or 9 people. I never missed a conversation my team was having and if I eve

robyates Dec 25, 2013 View on HN

I enjoy the open floor plan as well. The ease in which I can have conversations with my manager (assuming they are sitting near to me) is probably the biggest benefit. I feel this makes me more productive since more impromptu conversations can take place. Being able to listen in on any random coworker conversations and nerf gun battles is nice as well. However, on the few occasions when private space in necessary, then an office would be preferred. Of course, many others prefer individual offic

Ologn Oct 10, 2016 View on HN

I don't know why this is not discussed more. People either talk about either open floor plans or complete private solo offices. Or cubicles, although no one seems to like that.A private office with your team of 4-5 people seems ideal. You don't get the interruptions and noise of open floor plans, or even cubicles. You're also not alone and isolated all day. Your team is right around you to discuss any issues. It also helps build team cohesion. It is the best setup in m

pilgrim689 Apr 19, 2015 View on HN

I'm a big proponent of ~3 people offices as opposed to an open floor plan. There are many ways to "opt-in" to interactions:- lunch/dinner is done in a dining area- I invite people out for a coffee break- I can go hangout in a common area- I can just walk in to someone's office just like I would walk to someone's desk in an open floor plan- I bump into people while walking down the hall, grabbing a snack from the kitchen, etc.There's just so ma

idkMaybeImonly1 Jan 15, 2015 View on HN

I used to think like you guys, how the fuck would I get any work done if I'm in the middle with so many people doing so many different things in the same time. Someone is narrating his/her life story, other one talking about his views on x and so on. However, after working on similar environment for a year and now working on a really private cubes. I prefer the open spaces, it's more fun. YOU CANNOT SLACK IN OPEN SPACES. I used only code code code whole day and now in a private cu

city41 Nov 21, 2013 View on HN

I currently work in an open office and I really hate it. I've previously had jobs with cubicles and one job where everyone got their own full fledged office. Of the three, I actually think cubicles are the best.Everyone having their own private office was detrimental in the opposite way. Everyone was closed off and really inaccessible. Knocking on someone's door felt invasive and wrong, so people would avoid doing it.Cubicles give everyone privacy and space, but not so much that