Commute Times Debate

Commenters debate average commute lengths, the luxury of short commutes like 10-30 minutes, and strategies such as living near work or using public transit, contrasting experiences in cities like SF, Boston, and Paris.

πŸ“‰ Falling 0.3x Career & Jobs
3,433
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#6421
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
2
2008
12
2009
12
2010
46
2011
73
2012
81
2013
124
2014
114
2015
201
2016
282
2017
349
2018
349
2019
312
2020
229
2021
282
2022
274
2023
313
2024
213
2025
158
2026
7

Keywords

US MUNI NZ WFH DC openstreetmap.org RV NOVA NYC census.gov commute commuting suburbs minutes city live train downtown area commutes

Sample Comments

sulam β€’ Jun 12, 2018 β€’ View on HN

You can trivially get a 30 minute commute just within SF. I imagine other expensive cities are similar. Living within a few minutes of work is a real luxury for all but remote workers.

65 β€’ Nov 18, 2022 β€’ View on HN

You could try living in a city where you can commute via train. 1 hour on a train is significantly different than 1 hour driving a car.

brianwawok β€’ Apr 29, 2021 β€’ View on HN

Live in an area with a better commute. Mine is 8 minutes.

AdrianB1 β€’ Feb 25, 2019 β€’ View on HN

In some cities 1 hour commute is from one side of the city to the center or the other way around, not from suburbs to city. My commute is 1.5 hours per direction inside the city, going out would take more. Also spending 2 hours in a car, even self driven, is not the best way to spend your time. Otherwise you can live in a RV parked in front of your office.

alexhutcheson β€’ Sep 23, 2019 β€’ View on HN

2-3 hours commuting is not the norm. The average commute in the US is around 25 minutes each way, so roughly 1 hour total. Super-long commutes are almost non-existent outside a handful of metro areas.If you’re dealing with a very long commute, it might be worth it to move to a different metro, even if it requires a substantial pay cut. I think most people under-estimate the negative impact that a long commute has on their life.

danabrams β€’ Feb 7, 2020 β€’ View on HN

90 minutes is a megacommute? I need to move.

supergeek133 β€’ Nov 29, 2018 β€’ View on HN

Is it transportation or just short commute/ease of commute?I live in Minneapolis, for awhile I used to work in the southern suburbs. On a good day the drive was 30 minutes during rush hour. On a bad day you were talking 1-2 hours.Now I live 10 minutes from work, and I can't imagine doing anything else. Even when I speak to recruiters I increase my salary ask and tell them it's for the commute. I get laughed at.Meanwhile I talk to people that live 45-60 minutes away just s

alkonaut β€’ Jul 30, 2016 β€’ View on HN

Relaxing during a commute seems only marginally better than driving. What makes a difference is if you can work during the commute, so an entire 8h workday will be 2h commute and 6h work.In large metropolitan areas most people will end up spending what they can afford on housing, the choice is just between a 1h commute and large back yard and forest/beach within walking distance, versus the city with short commutes and shops/services within walking distance.You could live

ghaff β€’ Dec 2, 2025 β€’ View on HN

In most places (SF may be somewhat of an exception in terms of relatively unaffordable housing in both the city and any accessible suburbs) 30-60 minute commutes are pretty normal. At least a lot of the companies are probably in the suburbs/exurbs anyway. I'm not suggesting living in the middle of nowhere but, in a lot of places, urban vs. exurban living is a choice especially with companies that are often exurban.

bagels β€’ Nov 30, 2022 β€’ View on HN

Which cities? Silicon Valley? Or people remote working in the Midwest?If you are making Faang money you can choose a shorter commute. 30 miles is 1-2 hours in silicon valley. My limit is 10 miles/40 mins