Keyboard vs Mouse Efficiency

The cluster debates the superiority of keyboard-only workflows, shortcuts, and tools like Vim/Emacs over mouse usage for productivity, emphasizing reduced context-switching and precision in programming and general computing tasks.

📉 Falling 0.4x Hardware
4,206
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#6189
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
3
2008
57
2009
100
2010
155
2011
208
2012
230
2013
232
2014
142
2015
140
2016
192
2017
285
2018
181
2019
326
2020
318
2021
428
2022
314
2023
335
2024
282
2025
253
2026
25

Keywords

e.g AskTog IBM API COVID CAD PKM M570 GPT GarageBand mouse keyboard vim window keyboard mouse emacs faster clicking click muscle memory

Sample Comments

SkyMarshal Jun 1, 2021 View on HN

It's all about avoiding context-switching from keyboard to mouse and back.

blktiger Jan 13, 2014 View on HN

Every once in a while it's much faster to just reach for the mouse than to use keyboard shortcuts.

SkyMarshal Feb 11, 2021 View on HN

You can make keyboard more efficient than mouse for everything, even browsing code and googling. Tiling window manager + vim or emacs editor + vim or similar keybinds for browser.It takes some upfront work to get those keybinds into muscle memory, but once you're over that hump a mouse feels cumbersome and clumsy by comparison.

syndicatedjelly Jan 15, 2024 View on HN

Mine is: Don't waste time finding the "best" program for a particular task. Rather, find one that exposes keybindings for every action in the program, and then commit those bindings to muscle memory. This applies to:- design tools (Photoshop, Figma)- media-editing programs (GarageBand, whatever is used for video-editing these days)- unexpected places (e.g. Trello)The mouse has only 3-6 degrees of freedom to interact with. Only two digits on one hand operate a mouse. A

cicero Apr 13, 2016 View on HN

Mice are not a 100% replacement for keyboards. If you're doing lots of typing, there is something to be said for keeping your hands on the keyboard. Vim and emacs facilitate this much better than GUI-based editors.

colordrops Jun 1, 2021 View on HN

I hate the analog-like nature of the mouse - having to move where you want, then slow down until you get to the right spot, then click, then click again because the cursor is a character or two off; and going through menus is a pain. And it's worse when you are hungover or tired. I just want a discrete and quick way to move around, and after using vim for a long time, it's not even a question that it's way faster and easier than a mouse. A mouse is a huge drag once you are stron

jbeja Dec 29, 2013 View on HN

You know that there is something more efficient than the mouse, like the HUD or keyboard shortcuts?

SmileyKeith Jan 13, 2014 View on HN

I would lose years if I used the mouse in the terminal..

JoshMnem Apr 27, 2018 View on HN

I don't think the keyboard could be described as a limitation. It gives such precise control over editing that you can look at a file and then perform complex edits without looking at the screen.The mouse is probably an afterthought because using the mouse is significantly slower than the keyboard commands.When you have enough commands in muscle memory and use it as designed, it's almost like a telepathic communication with the computer.Everyone has their own preferences thoug

mokanfar Jun 5, 2020 View on HN

hard to get around not using the mouse eventually when looking up docs or copy pasting from browser