Google Monopoly Debate

Discussions revolve around whether Google has a monopoly in search and advertising markets, its dominant behaviors, and antitrust concerns.

➡️ Stable 0.7x Startups & Business
3,791
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#6071
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
3
2008
21
2009
85
2010
53
2011
91
2012
94
2013
102
2014
126
2015
131
2016
98
2017
334
2018
351
2019
373
2020
446
2021
309
2022
213
2023
313
2024
310
2025
311
2026
29

Keywords

CS e.g US GP AdWords YouTube DuckDuckGo google.com economicshelp.org SRE monopoly google search market bing search engine microsoft google search dominance competition

Sample Comments

Timber-6539 Nov 19, 2024 View on HN

A far worse monopoly than Google is going to solve your monopoly problem?

icey Dec 2, 2009 View on HN

What does Google have a monopoly over?

tzs Dec 18, 2010 View on HN

Google is massively bigger than Yahoo or Bing. They have or are close to having monopoly power in search (It doesn't take 100% to be a monopoly for antitrust purposes). When a company achieves that much dominance in a market, regulators generally frown on them using that dominance to gain power in other markets.

danaris Aug 22, 2025 View on HN

I mean, of course they can. They're Google. What are you going to do, stop using Chrome and searching with Google and using Gmail and buying AdWords and....etc?This is what happens when you have a monopoly.

Schroedingersat Jun 21, 2022 View on HN

Google is, and acts exactly like a monopoly in search. They intentionally degrade the effectiveness of their search to support their otyer business. Even when they are trying, they have been getting progressively worse at finding the real content, and many times put the same 5 garbage spam sites into the top 5 positions for a huge variety of searches. They even use their monopoly position to bully the entire world into degenerating all online content into a homogeneous soup of gpt-3 generated gi

dangoldin Apr 21, 2008 View on HN

Seems like a way for Google to increase their monopoly =)

zzzcpan Sep 12, 2018 View on HN

Think about it this way: there are plenty of products and services that you can't advertise anywhere else but on google search, so Google has a monopoly on that. This monopoly exists because of Google's abusive practices to prevent competition from entering the market it wants to own.

lallysingh May 4, 2018 View on HN

Monopoly on what? google.com? Android?Google's power comes from its (a) technical prowess and (b) popularity of some of its products. Many of their products get a large advantage just from being on their own internal platform.But I can't think of a product of theirs that doesn't have a strong competitor. Search is the strongest they have, and the underlying problem's getting a bit simpler (I believe it's substantially cheaper now to pay for the infrastructure f

foota Jun 27, 2017 View on HN

The idea is that Google has a monopoly in search. Monopoly is generally viewed as not a good thing. One thing you can do when you have a monopoly in one market is to try and extend it into another market. This is what Google is doing by showing their shopping results for searches. This would be viewed as acceptable for, say, Bing to do because Bing doesn't have a search monopoly.

otabdeveloper4 Oct 22, 2021 View on HN

Google is a monopoly, they don't have to be good.