Experiment Validity Debate
Commenters question the methodology, reproducibility, robustness, and conclusions of a specific experiment from the post, often requesting links, replications, or more robust designs.
Activity Over Time
Top Contributors
Keywords
Sample Comments
What if it is some kind of experiment?
Do you have a link to this experiment?
Feel free to share your experiments, I cannot reproduce them but you seem very sure about your stance so I am convinced you gave it a try, right ?
That was the experiment they did?
That would be nice, but then you're not doing an experiment.
what makes you think they’re not still doing experiments like this?
Let's see how that experiment works out.
this would be interesting if the experiment were more robust...
It's a cool experiment, but why post this — there aren't any conclusions yet!
Because of a single experiment in highly controlled environment :) Please come back to earth.