Car Feature Subscriptions

Comments criticize automakers like Tesla, BMW, and GM for locking hardware features behind software paywalls, subscriptions, and remote controls, arguing that buyers do not truly own their vehicles but subscribe to services with risks of privacy invasion and feature removal.

📉 Falling 0.3x Hardware
2,770
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#5978
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
1
2008
4
2009
4
2010
14
2011
19
2012
25
2013
56
2014
50
2015
89
2016
122
2017
87
2018
129
2019
108
2020
206
2021
321
2022
425
2023
489
2024
307
2025
292
2026
22

Keywords

MS US youtu.be CarPlay eetimes.com OEM UI FSF www.fsf DLC car cars subscription features manufacturers software buy car company car just like car

Sample Comments

thesuperbigfrog Nov 23, 2022 View on HN

It's not fully "your vehicle" if they control the software:https://youtu.be/Ag1AKIl_2GM?t=57You can pay a recurring subscription fee to access features that they own.

SoftTalker Mar 3, 2023 View on HN

Yep. Like software, car manufacturers want a car to be something you subscribe to rather than buy. Also lets them continue to receive income from secondhand sales or ownership changes.

Barrin92 Jun 9, 2019 View on HN

It primarily feels bad because unlike a spotify subscription, people still expect to own the cars they buy for tens of thousands of dollars, and this very effectively demonstrates how people who own the software you use can change what your car does with the push of a remote.If I buy a traditional car that accidentally came with a premium feature, is the cardealer going to come to my house and rip the seat out?

worik Jan 26, 2024 View on HN

I do not want my car reporting on meI do not need "over the air" updatesSell me the car. I will drive it away and make my own arrangements for maintenance.I want an asset, not a subscriptionOld man shouting at clouds?

ta1243 Sep 7, 2023 View on HN

Imagine a car manufacturer sold a car which was just a normal car. It didn't spy on you, it didn't rely on subscription for built in functionality, if you wanted something non-standard (say parking cameras or fancy paint color whatever) you paid for them upfront for a one off $x fee.Chances are nobody would care, but just buy what peer pressure tells them to buy.

MaxBarraclough Oct 31, 2020 View on HN

Tesla aren't the only car company to dabble with a business model based on what the FSF calls antifeatures. [0] Mercedes and BMW have done similar things. [1][2][0] https://www.fsf.org/blogs/community/antifeatures[1] <a href="https://www.thecarconnection.com/news/1121248_mercedes-benz-to-unlock-optional-tech-for-a-price-after-cars-a

helf Nov 21, 2022 View on HN

Microtransactions, subscriptions for damn near everything, in-app purchasing for every little addon, *aaS...I hate the modern tech world in a lot of ways. It is ridiculous.OEMs: "oooh.. EVs are just computers with Wheels. I bet we can do the same thing everyone else is doing!"I really, really hope there is so much backlash that they drop it. It should be illegal to purposefully gimp something like a car just to milk more money out of it.I can understand something that has t

TomVDB Nov 26, 2022 View on HN

My Model Y has a $2000 in-app purchase option to increase acceleration by something like 0.5s.It’s not a subscription, but the idea is the same.It doesn’t bother me one bit: I bought the car knowing full well that it wasn’t included, I don’t need it (the standard acceleration is already more than I ever had before), end of story.Car engines have been under the control of software for decades now, with different products differing by the program. The only difference here is that there’s

pmontra Jul 23, 2025 View on HN

Probably because if you and me would write one and install it on our cars it would void all certifications and make the car not legal to drive. That doesn't mean that manufacturers could not band together and make a common OS for cars, or a company in that market could not sell its software to everybody (like MS or Google) but I believe that manufactures don't want to completely commoditize cars and go the way of gas brands or smartphones. A car is 4 wheels, steering and brakes to me,

zoover2020 Sep 14, 2024 View on HN

It's easy to complain since they're the only manufacturer who opens up your car as an API