Suburbs vs Urban Living

The cluster debates the merits and drawbacks of suburban living compared to dense, walkable cities in the US, focusing on family preferences, car dependency, space, zoning, and urban sprawl.

📉 Falling 0.2x Politics & Society
4,801
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#5805
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
1
2008
47
2009
56
2010
43
2011
45
2012
53
2013
88
2014
158
2015
173
2016
360
2017
294
2018
308
2019
363
2020
347
2021
482
2022
601
2023
662
2024
429
2025
277
2026
14

Keywords

e.g US www.npr HN wikipedia.org ZONING DFW reddit.com USA McMansion suburbs suburban cities suburb urban live car sprawl city living

Sample Comments

hot_gril Feb 8, 2024 View on HN

It's not some perverse feeling of superiority or hatred of walking, but suburbs and cars are easier for families, especially large ones. The dense urban areas in the US tend to have more young and single people.

ajuc May 12, 2025 View on HN

Living in suburbs instead of in dense walkable cities is a choice as well.

nradov Jun 9, 2021 View on HN

Retirement isn't the issue. Most people who live in suburban areas today close to live in low density areas. They don't want their neighborhoods to become urban regardless of what that would mean for proximity to jobs and other desirable features.Stop trying to tell people what they ought to want. Not everyone agrees.

hanniabu Aug 7, 2021 View on HN

Many choose suburbs because there aren't walkable cities as an option

philwelch Dec 13, 2012 View on HN

There are advantages and disadvantages to urban and suburban life, and different people prefer different things. There isn't some universal human urge to live in suburbs. The cheap availability of automobile transport simply adjusts the cost benefit by reducing costs, as does racism.I suppose another factor is that Americans don't really do cities right, but this is largely an effect of the other two factors, plus the awkward way the American political system gives disproportionate influence

tick_tock_tick May 9, 2022 View on HN

Yes, in the USA people choose between living in a city or suburb. If you pick suburb you need to use a car all the time or be on one of the few major rail lines. People are just bringing up how this design seem to capture some of the worst parts of suburb living while managing to doge the benefits of city living.

nxor Oct 16, 2025 View on HN

Definitely. Are you in the US? Here in the suburbs things are just awful. Massive houses with 1 to 2 people, massive yards, many suburbanites grow no plants at all. It's very different from both rural neighborhoods and urban neighborhoods. But suburbanites tend to like it, and recent urban sprawl decisions in my area have been approved despite voices against them. And again to your question, people aren't happy with commutes now ... to get _anywhere_ in American suburbs you have to dri

refurb Jul 4, 2021 View on HN

Possible solution: you live in a dense urban area and people who want to live in the suburbs live there?

allthenews Jul 10, 2018 View on HN

Isn't that what suburbs are for?

epolanski Sep 1, 2024 View on HN

Suburban housing is one of the most inefficient ways to build cities.Suburbs make everything car centric.Everything is far, services are more complex and expensive to offer, public transport non existent.I really find suburbs from my experience in Ohio 10 years ago, as an European, an ugly distopia.And I haven't even got to other serious issues they have like absolute lack of socialization. Very little to no place to gather for local elders, dangerous for kids to walk/bike.