Nokia's Decline

This cluster centers on Nokia's fall from mobile phone dominance, debating management decisions like sticking with Symbian/MeeGo, pivoting to Windows Phone with Microsoft under Elop, and whether adopting Android or other strategies could have prevented their downfall.

➡️ Stable 0.6x Startups & Business
4,986
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#5590
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
8
2008
25
2009
61
2010
227
2011
863
2012
549
2013
649
2014
350
2015
206
2016
284
2017
159
2018
165
2019
116
2020
250
2021
187
2022
231
2023
212
2024
192
2025
242
2026
10

Keywords

MS ARM MeGo ANOTHER N800 PC S40 N9 CEO SCO nokia android windows phone phone microsoft phones ms windows mobile smartphone

Sample Comments

chmike Sep 7, 2013 View on HN

Could this have saved nokia from it's debacle ?

jessaustin Sep 10, 2014 View on HN

Nokia would have been better off...

kramerger Nov 10, 2023 View on HN

Alternative take: Nokia was before is time

dshep Sep 3, 2022 View on HN

Nokia suffered from lack of direction from the top... They had both symbian and maemo, both officially blessed, but incompatible. Symbian was the past and maemo had promise, so what did management do... a hail mary bet on microsoft? It came out of nowhere and seemed desperate, I believe the market's reaction reflected this sadly.

Zigurd Jun 13, 2025 View on HN

Nokia had credible mobile OSs for modern phones. Windows Phone was not one.

kyberneticka Feb 11, 2011 View on HN

I didn't say it was wise. I just believe that it is the reality of the situation. We have watched Nokia throw their immense resources in every direction, from Symbian to Maemo to Meego, all resulting in failure. The pathways for Nokia to take were pretty narrow, and I think spending more time in developing yet ANOTHER platform would have been death. Nokia cut their losses here, and went with a platform they could work with. They can focus their efforts on developing killer hardware and optimizin

ThomPete Sep 3, 2013 View on HN

they didnt buy Nokia, they bought part of Nokia no?

agumonkey Oct 2, 2016 View on HN

Are there any articles in english about this ? Why would the Nokia board throw this huge empire in the ground ? They won more by selling the mobile phone div. than by trying to compete ?

trm42 Feb 14, 2016 View on HN

According to rumors Nokia had lots of discussion with MS and Google about which platform they should take. Got the impression that the proposition from MS was somehow better and at least initially gave more room to move for Nokia. Later on got the impression that lots of things didn't went as was promised.But, Nokia is still alive and the situation seems to be a lot rosier for them after selling the mobile phone business. They got good price and got really cheap loan from Microsoft as pa

wood_spirit Nov 1, 2025 View on HN

(Nokia went from king to pauper in the year when the iPhone and then Android launched. They death spiralled and Elop was brought in a few years later to transition them to using Microsoft Windows mobile. However, windows mobile was as old and uncompetitive as Symbian so couldn’t compete. Was very obvious at the time although the boards seem to have been living in their dream worlds)