Torrent Piracy Legality

Comments debate the legal risks of torrenting pirated content, focusing on the distinction between downloading (often legal) and uploading/seeding (illegal in many jurisdictions), with warnings about default client behaviors.

➡️ Stable 0.6x Legal
5,838
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#5493
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
11
2008
35
2009
179
2010
186
2011
358
2012
795
2013
290
2014
317
2015
275
2016
303
2017
280
2018
236
2019
213
2020
451
2021
333
2022
363
2023
392
2024
362
2025
436
2026
23

Keywords

US CLI MPAA DRM a.c IA HTTPS YouTube copyright.gov RIAA downloading illegal copyrighted torrents download uploading content torrent legal sharing

Sample Comments

robswc Jul 23, 2025 View on HN

AFAIK, downloading or watching pirated stuff isn't something you'll get in trouble for. Hosting and distributing it is what will get you.

esMazer Feb 4, 2014 View on HN

what are they going to do when people download illegal torrents to it?

terhechte Apr 7, 2016 View on HN

Absolutely. I'm just asking because in certain jurisdictions seeding (illegal content) will lead to huge fines, and not mentioning this on the homepage might lead people to believe that they can safely use this software. This is especially worrying since "streaming" is oftentimes understood as a read-only operation which cannot be pursued by law enforcement.

ta988 Oct 6, 2021 View on HN

Depends on your local legislations, but be careful that by default on torrents you are also sharing those files to others so you are also distributing stolen material, so it may have an impact on your potential "crime".

zeroq Feb 21, 2025 View on HN

It's an interesting case.Most commonly used clients won't let you turn off seeding, but you can indeed limit the upstream to a really low value. You can also, at the same time, seed a ton of different things, preferably quite large, to saturate your upload and make it statistically improbable to fully send a copy of any single file.Now, based on my feeling and cases I've seen in my country I'd say that the judge would make a claim that the sheer fact of ma

Kenji Mar 12, 2015 View on HN

You are mistaken. In many countries an explicit, legal line is drawn between uploading and downloading copyrighted material, and some allow downloading because otherwise clicking on a link might already incriminate you. What k___ is saying is that it's the illegal upload part that moves people away from torrent.

h91wka Sep 12, 2018 View on HN

That still makes torrenting illegal

Jleagle Mar 12, 2024 View on HN

Similar argument to bittorrent. Using it is perfectly legal, using it to download movies is illegal.

hulitu Feb 13, 2023 View on HN

Torrenting copyrighted material is illegal in some (democratic) countries.

FlyingSnake Mar 11, 2016 View on HN

How do you handle illegal torrents, piracy etc?