Phone Cases Debate

Users debate the necessity of phone cases for protecting modern smartphones, sharing personal anecdotes about drops, screen cracks, and the increasing durability of devices like recent iPhones without cases.

➡️ Stable 0.6x Hardware
3,473
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#5487
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
2
2008
4
2009
10
2010
83
2011
77
2012
253
2013
184
2014
225
2015
110
2016
188
2017
224
2018
217
2019
227
2020
237
2021
234
2022
240
2023
332
2024
275
2025
345
2026
6

Keywords

G1 ID PS i.e N900 SGS2 S2 AppleCare phone phones iphone screen dropped dropping drop cracked break glass

Sample Comments

standardUser • Aug 14, 2024 • View on HN

I've used minimalist cases for my the last 3 or 4 phones, dropped them all plenty of times, and never suffered more than a minor scratch on the screen. I assume phones are just much tougher than 10 years ago, but the case isn't hurting the cause and I'm too scared not to use one.

r00fus • Aug 22, 2022 • View on HN

Anecdote - my wife went through 3 iPhone screens in the course of 18 months due to dropped phones (6, 8, 8) but then she got a plus-sized iPhone and an otter box case and hasn't broken one in years.

j_maffe • Sep 24, 2024 • View on HN

But don't people use phone cases anyway to protect these fragile devices? what's the point then?

cube2222 • May 2, 2021 • View on HN

I've had this attitude before, but I must say, the recent iPhones at least (iPhone 11 in my case) are ridiculously resistant to damage.Mine is not in a case and regularly has scary-looking falls, but there's almost no-scratch. Only on the edges of the aluminum body you can see the paint scratched off in some places.I've found that the added bulk of a case makes me drop my phone much more frequently.

imbnwa • Jan 7, 2021 • View on HN

Maybe it handles falls so your phone doesn't have to?

marknutter • Nov 11, 2025 • View on HN

The phones are incredibly tough, I have never used a case and I've only cracked my screen once and that was like 8 years ago.

sumedh • Oct 14, 2020 • View on HN

I dont use a screen protector but have a good case to handle the falls, so far so good.

clarky07 • Apr 9, 2015 • View on HN

i haven't had a case on my iPhone in 6 years. the screens do not in fact break easily. some people are more clumsy than others. some just prefer to have a case for whatever reason. the same is true for android phones.

pphysch • Oct 20, 2021 • View on HN

You don't use phone cases, I take it?

sigi45 • Oct 30, 2018 • View on HN

Exactly!Slim sleack shiny phones which break when dropped. Easily dropped because of shiny slippery surface.What to do? Put some cheap something around it.....And I'm wondering why people ask me why I don't have a case around my phone.I don't get the thin phone to have more space for the plastic protection that's why...