Difficult Coworkers Debate

Comments debate the value of competent but unpleasant 'jerks' versus nice, collaborative coworkers in tech teams, highlighting how difficult personalities harm morale, productivity, and the importance of interpersonal skills.

📉 Falling 0.3x Career & Jobs
4,775
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#5436
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
12
2008
44
2009
85
2010
83
2011
137
2012
144
2013
177
2014
142
2015
208
2016
243
2017
324
2018
297
2019
371
2020
287
2021
531
2022
527
2023
501
2024
325
2025
305
2026
32

Keywords

FIRE FAANG IMO PhDs coworkers team jerk jerks person personalities competent skill working mediocre

Sample Comments

bigbillheck Jan 17, 2022 View on HN

One doesn't appreciate nice coworkers until one has had to deal with the alternative.

diminoten Oct 17, 2019 View on HN

Sorry, but your inability to interact with your co-workers makes you a difficult person to employ. A ton of folks don't need this kind of special treatment.

esskay Jan 19, 2023 View on HN

You must be a joy to work with. I feel sorry for the rest of your team, having to deal with that kind of view on everything.

vsareto Mar 29, 2023 View on HN

>I guess I'm just good at working with them and ignoring their jerkiness, so I keep ending up working with them?This is definitely a skill. You can have, what seems to be, a bunch of jerks working together but they all have thick-skin so being a jerk to one another doesn't really affect any of them. Effectively hiring for this team is an exercise in finding people who think like they do.Good meshing of personalities can override the predictions of the incompetent/niceness

kindfellow92 Dec 22, 2017 View on HN

Yeah after enough projects and jobs, I think the morale and productivity cost of having people with whom are difficult to work is too high. Jerks breed resentment and destroy the motivation of others. Companies are about large organized groups of people accomplishing a goal larger than any given individual could accomplish by themself. Individuals who can’t cooperate with others are literally destroying a core aspect of any company.

stuaxo Jul 14, 2025 View on HN

Feel like at least one coworker might be better if they were this.

flerchin Nov 2, 2021 View on HN

If you lack friendliness, trustworthiness, or competency; I'd prefer you work at a competitor's. All three are deal-breakers on my team.

sanderjd May 1, 2019 View on HN

Personally, I prefer working with less competent pleasant people than more competent unpleasant people. You can find useful stuff to give less competent people (and help them become more competent over time), but it's hard to avoid unpleasant people affecting the morale of a whole team.

gryzzly Mar 23, 2012 View on HN

there is something called "ethics" and "politeness". when you choose companions and collaborators, these are quite important values, obviously, the guy haven't heard of these words and obviously working with a person like that is not fun, you will then feel ashamed when he does something like this as a part of your team.

throwaway98797 Jun 20, 2022 View on HN

“Does not play well with others”he may be capable and probably is, but it doesn’t appear like the dev knows how to deal with less than stellar people.managing sub par people both up and down is an important skill.