Optical Media Durability

The cluster focuses on the longevity and degradation of optical media like CDs and DVDs for archival storage, with users sharing personal experiences of disc rot, data loss after 5-10 years, and alternatives like M-DISCs compared to HDDs.

📉 Falling 0.4x Hardware
1,774
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#5376
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
4
2009
9
2010
20
2011
21
2012
31
2013
33
2014
109
2015
65
2016
43
2017
73
2018
63
2019
136
2020
118
2021
145
2022
267
2023
214
2024
234
2025
170
2026
19

Keywords

mamgold.html www.vice mediasupply.com nvlpubs.nist DVD goldcdr.html imation.com HDD LTO CD discs cd dvd optical dvds media cds rs disc rot

Sample Comments

MikeW Aug 30, 2008 View on HN

I've found that optical media like CD-Rs and DVD-Rs corrode over time. Many of the CD-Rs I burned over the last 7 years are unreadable now. Different media seems to degrade at different speeds. Beware of burning a DVD, storing it away for 10 years and trying to read it then.

wmf May 25, 2023 View on HN

It's not necessarily as bad as you think: https://blog.dshr.org/2022/08/optical-media-durability-updat...

suddencoma Jun 5, 2020 View on HN

Yeah, CD/DVD media degrades over time, often on the time span of a decade they become unreadable. They are a bad choice for long term storage.

snmx999 Jun 12, 2023 View on HN

You could use M-DISCs, which look like traditional CDs nut are made for long-term storage and should be readable much longer than other CDs, DVDs and Blu-rays. The optical drives for burning M-DISCs are readily available and not very expensive.

ska Nov 24, 2023 View on HN

I've never really heard of that being a thing except for ones you burn yourself. Optical media is pretty stable unless (re) writable, so I'm surprised. I've played 20 year old DVDs without issue, fwiw.

yjftsjthsd-h Feb 18, 2020 View on HN

Doesn't optical media degrade to the point of no longer being readable after a few years?

tmountain Jul 5, 2024 View on HN

Curious why the media is more durable than CD-Rs which are known to degrade after 5-10 years (give or take).

pengaru Feb 18, 2020 View on HN

My personal experience has been surprisingly good even with cheap TDK CDRs I burned in the 90s still reading just fine decades later.For especially valuable data you want to preserve for 100+ years, there are "archival quality" discs [0] [1].[0] http://mam-a-store.com/goldcdr.html[1] https://ww

mrjin Oct 7, 2022 View on HN

Chose CD/DVD as archival medium was one of the big mistakes I've ever made. Most CDs/DVDs failed just after around 10 years. HDDs seem to be much more reliable.

bitboxer Aug 8, 2010 View on HN

No, it won't. Some CDs from the early 90ies are not playable anymore because the foil that stores the data is damaged through aging processes. DVDs and hard drives have similar problems and won't last longer than 5-15 years if you are not lucky.