Police Lying Legality

Discussions center on the legal asymmetry where police can lie to suspects during interrogations without consequence, while citizens face crimes like perjury or obstruction for lying to police.

📉 Falling 0.3x Legal
3,849
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#5364
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
1
2008
4
2009
31
2010
44
2011
82
2012
86
2013
307
2014
166
2015
212
2016
177
2017
265
2018
273
2019
399
2020
302
2021
370
2022
273
2023
383
2024
270
2025
198
2026
8

Keywords

AFAIK e.g US XYZ TLDR FBI UK IANAL E.g NEVER lie police lying crime lied guilty court cop testimony lawyer

Sample Comments

smsm42 Jun 9, 2013 View on HN

For police to lie to a suspect - or anybody else - is not against the law and AFAIK does not violate "due process". Giving false testimony however - which two girlfriends were about to do - is a crime, called perjury. So the prosecutor actually prevented two crimes from being committed.

ams6110 Aug 15, 2011 View on HN

They also can lie when they interrogate you. They can tell you your friend has already implicated you in the crime, even if it's not true.

etrabroline Jun 23, 2020 View on HN

Yes, they can lie during an interrogation to make you confess. Not during a trial.

grasshopperpurp Jul 26, 2017 View on HN

Doesn't perjury already apply?

tempestn Mar 19, 2015 View on HN

Lying to the police, even by intentionally misinterpreting the question, is probably a bad idea.

gknoy Sep 12, 2013 View on HN

Since it's trivial to show whether or not that is true, I would not advise making such a thing. It is highly inadvisable to lie to the police or courts.

sillysaurus3 May 15, 2017 View on HN

It's illegal to lie to investigators. (They're allowed to lie to you, but not vice-versa.)

AngryData Apr 17, 2025 View on HN

Cops can lie with impunity while in uniform, why would an undercover cop not lie to you?

zaroth May 18, 2015 View on HN

This is actually their standard line, almost verbatim. Replace XYZ law with 'lying to me is illegal' and 'if you make this hard it will much worse for you and I won't be able to help you...' It is a long and well established right for the police to use deception to gain confessions. They will Mirandize you and then convince and cajole you into waiving your rights. They do it every day, and in almost every case.

ams6110 Apr 20, 2011 View on HN

They can't lie about them afterwards, but they can lie to you during interrogation. E.g. "your friend Joe already told us you did so you might as well admit it." even if that's not true.