Sandbox Games Narratives

Discussions focus on emergent storytelling, procedural generation, and player-driven narratives in sandbox and open-world games like Dwarf Fortress, Minecraft, and Factorio, contrasting them with linear narratives and exploring game design challenges for chaos and replayability.

📉 Falling 0.5x Gaming
3,196
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#5308
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
2
2008
24
2009
24
2010
74
2011
65
2012
108
2013
117
2014
132
2015
131
2016
196
2017
160
2018
148
2019
215
2020
224
2021
251
2022
381
2023
323
2024
282
2025
325
2026
14

Keywords

e.g AI MineCraft TON raphkoster.com GTA OK youtu.be CDPR L4D2 game games fortress dwarf play mechanics sandbox player games like fun

Sample Comments

ralusek Aug 5, 2025 View on HN

It's interesting, because I was always a bit confused and annoyed by the Giant's Drink/Mind Game that Ender plays in Ender's Game. It just always felt so different to how games I knew played, it felt odd that he would "discover" things that the developers hadn't intended, because I always just thought "wait, someone had to build that into the game just in case he happened to do that one specific thing?" Or if it was implied that they didn't do th

summerlight Mar 13, 2024 View on HN

Easier said than done. I assume you have no prior experience on professional game development? Many game designers tried to tame chaos as a game mechanic in the name of "emergent gameplay" and only a few of them survived through numerous iterations in an extremely limited format. I would recommend you to do your own research before making such a bold statement. It is not that people cannot come up with the same idea; many cases they tried it and there's a good reason not to do tha

imbnwa Sep 29, 2022 View on HN

The mechanics lend themselves to a sandbox with no primary narrative

crimsonalucard May 26, 2015 View on HN

The trailer implies that these games offer worlds of boundless possibility, what it really is, is worlds with a bunch of generated primitives and sliders to change some numerical parameter. It's not that the trailers for these games lie, it's just we subconsciously expected more.To achieve what we expect, the programmer needs to implement features that allow emergent gameplay and unpredictable situations to arise alongside procedurally generated settings. There are few single player

3minus1 Aug 16, 2017 View on HN

this sounds really cool. some of my favorite games are essentially sandboxes (mount & blade, pirates), and I like the idea of taking the sandbox and building in non-trivial, non-artificial non-deterministic stories.

cortesoft Feb 3, 2019 View on HN

It really depends on the type of game you play. There are a TON of open ended 'sand box' type games that don't do any of those things (City Builders, MineCraft, Factorio, etc).

EricE Apr 19, 2022 View on HN

I think that's a common problem for most games - at least it is for me.The cool thing about Dyson Sphere Program is there is so much to do in it, you can create your own end game scenarios.Also just because the blueprints are there, you don't have to use them. It does feel like cheating sometimes!

xyst Jan 19, 2022 View on HN

Say goodbye to originality in games

fir3dvst Mar 10, 2025 View on HN

Yes, you can use your imagination to do whatever you want in the game, that's the point. It's like a sandbox. It will generate new characters and adapt to you. Yet, if you want to win it, you have to try to achieve its goal.

Mithaldu Nov 14, 2015 View on HN

Not so much that he (he's made several games like that) is oblivious to it, but more that it's the most easy thing to simulate in games, and also what people expect. You can do better, as games like Untertale or KSP demonstrate. But it takes a special kind of person.